Do Extraordinary Claims Require Extraordinary Evidence?

[SteveII]

Bayesian reasoning. You use it for literally everything but your religious beliefs (drops mic).

And that is exactly what I was referring to in my probability discussion. You are stopping at one side of the probability calculus--just the probability of seeing miracle R|B over the probability of seeing not-R|B (the middle of the equation). You have to also assess the probability of E|R&B over the probability of seeing E|not-R&B. 



R = Resurrection 
B = Background information (the supernatural exists)
E = Evidence