Organic Molecules Found 400 Light Years From Earth

[rjh4 is back]

Atoms are the result of the death of prior suns. If you cannot accept that, I cannot help you. 

Your right, I don't like it, but not for personal reasons. I think you are taking this personally, not me.

Yes, I do defend facts tooth and nail. No, not one bit sorry or afraid.

Now go spend some time debating science with Jews and Muslims and Hindus and Buddhists for a few years like I have then come back to me and claim you are so different and unique.

Brian...I told you to take the atoms from the death of prior suns as a given. Whether I believe it or not, I conceded the point. So, go ahead and explain the life from non-life issue.

I can assure you Brian, I take none of this personally.

So far all I have seen from you is defending scenarios based on fact, not the facts themselves. Didn't you get the difference from my earlier post?

Look, Brian, my question regarding life from non-life is a relevant question even for an atheist (in other words my question would have just as much validity if I was an atheist). If your answer is you don't know, just admit it and we can move on. You can not know something and still be an atheist. Others that are here can, so you can too. But stop trying to make simplistic statements and assume you have covered it...because you haven't...and I think you know that.