Organic Molecules Found 400 Light Years From Earth

[Succubus]

I have a syllogism for you.

1) If the atheists other than Brian who have participated in  this thread think that rjh4 is wrong on an argument, they will address rjh4's argument.

2) The atheists other than Brian who have participated in this thread have not addressed rjh4's argument that Brian is full of BS when he said: "Close proximity of individual atoms that by themselves are not a living thing, but because they bond like magnets exchanging electrons, that makes it very easy to go from non life to life."

3) Therefore, the atheists other than Brian who have participated in this thread think rjh4 is right in his argument that Brian is full of BS when he said: "Close proximity of individual atoms that by themselves are not a living thing, but because they bond like magnets exchanging electrons, that makes it very easy to go from non life to life."

What do you think?  Is it valid and sound?

You're referring to yourself in the third person?