(August 18, 2011 at 2:33 pm)Rhythm Wrote: You can criticize the assumptions, as can I, but it's still a syllogism. Say it Statler, you know what I want to hear.
(I was very surprised that you went down this road, what with all of the syllogisms for god being fallacious, and yet, syllogisms)
Au contraire, I was surprised you went down this road with all the valid syllogisms for God's existence. I never said you could not present a valid syllogism for aliens; you just can't present a convincing sound syllogism, which of course you haven't. Many atheists require more proof for the existence of God than they do aliens, special pleading. You can’t see the problem there?
