Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic

[robvalue]

How is it at all problematic that extra requirements make things less likely? How else could it possibly work? This is basic probability, if not just common sense.

Of course, you might luck out and be trying to prove something that is actually true, but be doing it in an utterly flawed way so that you’re not demonstrating it.

This is all pretending that there’s any possible way to determine probabilities about things we have no data on whatsoever.