Lets get rid of primary elections when electing our president

[Clueless Morgan]

And I think that you need to discuss the reasons for a change.

I'm not saying that abolishing the electoral college would be a blanket good for the nation because it brings up the problem of the tyranny of the majority.  Those impulses would need to be checked so that minorities remain protected, be they atheists, religious minorities, racial and ethnic minorities, LGBT minorities, etc.

HOWEVER

The main problem that I have with the electoral college is the fact that some citizens are over represented and others are under represented.  For example, California has a population of 39.5 million and 55 electoral votes meaning each electoral vote represents 718,181 people.  In South Dakota, with 3 electoral votes and a population of 870,000, each electoral vote represents 290,000 people.  If every state had that many people per EV, California would have 136 electoral votes.

This country does not have equal representation either in our elected officials or in our electoral college which violates one of the core ideals upon which this country was founded: that all men are created equal.  Well, if we're really equal, then give us all equal representation.

Doesn't the principles still apply even without the issue of slavery though?   It's possibly a corollary explanation, but not a necessary one.  The reason is because they had less eligible voters,the "why" is secondary.   It doesn't make it a racist system.  The same reasoning still holds today, and nobody owns slaves.  And as you said, it is a compromise.  Areas with higher populations do have more electoral votes, and regions of the country with lower populations can't just be ignored.  Perhaps we can improve it, but I think that you will still need a compromise and popular vote is not necessarily better.

I only ever talked about a "compromise" in the context of the Three-Fifths compromise.

And it is true to say that we no longer have slaves.

It is also true to say that we have unequal representation in our government and that is ultimately the reason I would wish to abolish the electoral college.  I agree that areas of the country with lower populations shouldn't just be ignored, but neither should they have disproportionate power to influence our elections.

Everyone talks about one person one vote but that's not what we have.  We have, in California, 718,000 people one vote.  In South Dakota, 290,000 people one vote.  In Arizona, 639,000 people one vote.  In Wyoming, 139,000 people one vote. In New York, 683,000 people one vote. In Florida, which has the same number of electoral votes as New York, it's 723,600 people one vote.

That's crap.