RE: Beating women in Islam
November 7, 2018 at 2:04 am
(This post was last modified: November 7, 2018 at 2:06 am by WinterHold.)
But why do you complicate a direct, official command in a verse in the Quran?
Nothing is theoretical, rather everything is absolute in the Quran unless stated otherwise. It is an Arabic book, subject to Arab language and its laws.
This means: if you do "x", you will get "y".
Eg: if you rebel against your husband, and the rebellion is physical, he can meet the physical abuse with a similar physical abuse.
if you didn't rebel against your husband, he doesn't have the right to punish your action.
I think it's pretty clear; unlike human-made constitutions. I'm not seeing a gray area, rather a white/black situation, with white/black response.
You're assuming and building upon your own personal assumption; that is wrong.
Nothing is theoretical, rather everything is absolute in the Quran unless stated otherwise. It is an Arabic book, subject to Arab language and its laws.
This means: if you do "x", you will get "y".
Eg: if you rebel against your husband, and the rebellion is physical, he can meet the physical abuse with a similar physical abuse.
if you didn't rebel against your husband, he doesn't have the right to punish your action.
I think it's pretty clear; unlike human-made constitutions. I'm not seeing a gray area, rather a white/black situation, with white/black response.
You're assuming and building upon your own personal assumption; that is wrong.
