RE: Anti Trans And Why It Fails
December 21, 2018 at 8:06 am
(This post was last modified: December 21, 2018 at 8:08 am by Amarok.)
Quote:If It's not political, and not about rights then your topic has no discernable meaning.Nope one can talk about trans outside of politics or civil rights and it can be meaningful the fact you only see it as politics is your problem
Quote:It's nothing but a holier-than-thou rant.Nope it was a critique of a specific line of reasoning and why it doesn't work
Quote:"Some people don't like transgenders, but you do. So, you're going to tell everyone what you think. The end."Nope it was "here are bad arguments and here's why they are bad "
Quote:Your OP didn't ask a question.Didn't need too
Quote: you simply listed a bunch of alleged anti-trans question answered by you.Yup it was a critique of some arguments or a line of reasoning
Quote:In typical yappy puppy fashion you used oversimplified-to-the-point-of-being-nonsensical one line responses to your own statements.Nope the arguments were spot on not over simplistic and they only required one line to fail
Quote:You didn't ask a question,Didn't need too
Quote:you didn't posit a theory.A theory of what ? and why would this require a theory ?
Quote:You simple pretended that you know everything about why people don't accept transgender people.I never even discuss the why I talked about the arguments or at least one line of arguments again I made this pretty clear in my opening post .
Quote:The discussion is political whether you're smart enough to know it is or not.Nope the idea of trans can be discussed outside of politics
Quote:The discussion is about rights whether you're smart enough to know it or not.Nope what I was discussing was ontological not prescriptive you can talk about the former without
Quote:If you just don't want to have those discussions then there is no need for your bizarre rant in the first place.Nope I can do so without talking about either and there is nothing bizarre about my post
Quote:People can be free to love trans people or hate them based on their own moral compass and personal beliefs and we can all just stop bothering to talk about trans people...Nope
Quote:There doesn't actually seem to be a point to this thread other than you think something and everyone else is wrong.I stated point of the thread and it's not that
Quote:But hey! You clearly know everything about people who are anti-trans.Never claimed that in fact the opposite
Quote:So, I reckon it's all your fault for not handling the problem.Again never claimed that and I do help solve the problem
Quote:You think you know everything about it but haven't done a damn thing to relieve their non-political pain and suffering.Again never claimed that and i do just that you do so love to assume things about people
Quote:Now that I think of it, you really are a piece of shit for not using your vast knowledge of anti-trans sentiment for the advancement of trans-kind!Again never claimed that and I already do that and the only POS here pal is you as you have shown throughout this forum .
Seek strength, not to be greater than my brother, but to fight my greatest enemy -- myself.
Inuit Proverb
Inuit Proverb