(January 12, 2019 at 3:34 pm)T0 Th3 M4X Wrote:(January 12, 2019 at 3:03 pm)LadyForCamus Wrote: I think Brian is being hyperbolic for the sake of brevity. He can correct me, if I'm wrong, ofc. If you want little personal spiel, it goes something like this:
I have been on these forums for upwards of four years now, and I have never been presented with a positive case for the existence of god that wasn't either logically fallacious, or didn't misrepresent science in some fashion, or both. Unlike many of my cohorts here, atheism is not my preferred position. I would prefer that there be "something else", or something "more", beyond death. The fact is, no one has ever made a convincing case to me. No one has ever made a convincing case for the existence of the supernatural. No one has ever been able to give me a sound, positive description of what the supernatural is. So, I withhold belief until such a case is presented.
You have always been fair and you seem kind, so hopefully I can provide the same back to you.
It's not about what everybody else can prove or what others can show you. It's about you seeking regardless of your own personal biases. I can show you a million things and claim they are evidence, but until you experience God, you will have a reason to say that's not good enough, because that's not God. If our own human determination was the root problem, then how can we assume ourselves to be the solution? Seek the source by the source and its assumed attributes. That doesn't mean others can't assist you along the way, but as much as someone can be helpful, they can also be hurtful. Even if someone means well, they can give you misinformation.
If I wanted to find you (hypothetically), I would need to assume you have an identity, I would need to be willing to seek, I would need to know what attributes you have to recognize you, and no matter who anybody else says you are or where they say you are, I will only have found you when I matched you with what I know to be you. At that point, I will have accomplished my mission and you can hit me with a purse or a brick, or even shake my hand, but the latter is always preferred.
Lady, you are correct. I have been at this with countless theists since 01. I have no desire to wade down a Yellow Brick Road. Not, just with Christians, but anyone including, Muslims or Jews or Hindus or Buddhists. They may be the nicest people in the world outside the subject of religion. But once you accept the age of our species, our planet, our universe, it is hard to swallow old mythology of any kind.
It frightens most humans to think of themselves as finite. It shouldn't, but it does. I can value human rights, but I don't think any human should fear the consideration that what they once thought was fact was mere myth. If our species never questioned social norms, our species never would have left the caves.
Thomas Jefferson was a deist, whom wrote his own bible stripping it of all the fantastic claims. But, even with him, I would have argued, why the need for even that? And this is a guy who said, "Question with boldness even the existence of a god, for if there be one, surely he would pay more homage to reason, than to that of blindfolded fear."