(October 5, 2011 at 4:42 am)8BitAtheist Wrote: 1. Is it immoral to want someone to not exist?
No
2. Is it immoral to want someone to die?
No, but it is immoral to do something about it.
3. Is it immoral to want someone to fall into an abyss of obscurity?
No, what is a pit of obscurity anyway.......new jersey?
1. I'm not exactly sure, if you want someone to not exist it creates a theoretical hypothetical reality where they were never born and thus they can't die and you cannot wish for them to, and you'd also not be able to not exist either. So, maybe?
So thoughts can be sinfull. why?
it isnt thoughts that are the problem its actions that count.
2. I think it may be immoral to wish death upon someone.
You are again talking about wishing as though it makes a difference.
3. No, I don't think that that's immoral. For example if WPC were to fall off the face of the earth (figuratively [okay, maybe literally too]), I wouldn't mind one bit.
---
Thoughts?
Thought crimes are not crimes.
You can fix ignorance, you can't fix stupid.
Tinkety Tonk and down with the Nazis.
