RE: DNA Proves Existence of a Designer
March 14, 2019 at 6:11 pm
(This post was last modified: March 14, 2019 at 7:09 pm by Abaddon_ire.)
(March 14, 2019 at 1:43 am)CDF47 Wrote:(March 14, 2019 at 1:07 am)Peebo-Thuhlu Wrote: At work.
No CDF47.
it's not that we want you to just 'Read books' (Or even just we want you to 'Read science books')
We would like you to read/look into the actual science, as it were.
That you keep bringing up the likes of Meyer and Behe.
I know I've asked you to find/quote other sources. Any other sources from 'Your side'.
At least it will give us different errors, fibs, straw-men, misconceptions and nuttery to debunk.
A nice change of pace.
So..... you're happy with mtEve. (You're still misrepresenting the information but... *Shrug)
How do you reconcile that mtEve and yAdam never actually met/existed at the same time?
This'll be fun.
I've read plenty of science books in the past.
It is unknown whether the first MtEve and YAdam ever met.
You are claiming that they did. Prove it.
(March 14, 2019 at 1:43 am)CDF47 Wrote:(March 14, 2019 at 1:07 am)Peebo-Thuhlu Wrote: At work.
No CDF47.
it's not that we want you to just 'Read books' (Or even just we want you to 'Read science books')
We would like you to read/look into the actual science, as it were.
That you keep bringing up the likes of Meyer and Behe.
I know I've asked you to find/quote other sources. Any other sources from 'Your side'.
At least it will give us different errors, fibs, straw-men, misconceptions and nuttery to debunk.
A nice change of pace.
So..... you're happy with mtEve. (You're still misrepresenting the information but... *Shrug)
How do you reconcile that mtEve and yAdam never actually met/existed at the same time?
This'll be fun.
I've read plenty of science books in the past.
It is unknown whether the first MtEve and YAdam ever met.
But it is known that mtEve had a mother and at least one sister. And similarly, at least one aunt. It's right there in the definition of what mtEve actually is.
This is rather easy to prove, unlike most aspects of the theory.
1. Find any matrilineal lineage that leads to mtEve's mother.
2. Find any matrilineal lineage that does not lead to mtEve's mother.
3. Two tasks accomplished.
A. mtEve's mother exists.
and
B. mtEve's mother is not mtEve.
You are still missing the key word "matrilineal" either because you know that it is fatal to your argument or you simply are that stupid.
OK CDF, let's try this from a different direction.
There actually is a way that your idiotic belief that everyone can be traced back to one particular man and one particular woman can work quite easily.
The solution is really straightforward. You acknowledge that something in the region of 128 billion humans have ever existed. That's a fuzzy figure at best, but roughly works. Personally, in such discussions, I go with 120, but close enough. We can never reach any accurate count so approximations must suffice.
To make your idea work, all of them, all 128 billion of them male and female, without exception must have had at least one son and at least one daughter who both reproduced. That is the only way your daft idea can work. Were it otherwise, either a male or female lineage would go extinct.
You are claiming that this is so, everyone without exception must have had a minimum of one son AND one daughter.
Do you think that is a reasonable claim to make?