If I don't believe that a large jar full of gumballs contains exactly 537 gumballs, that doesn't mean it I believe it doesn't. It could. But I don't have enough information to agree that's the right number, and whoever claims that they do know the exact number ought to show the work by which they found out if they want me to buy in on their count, and their method should make sense and only be usable to arrive at 537, not some other numbers too. I'm not saying it's not 537, I'm saying I don't know, and likely neither do you.
I'm not anti-Christian. I'm anti-stupid.