Was Prophet Mohammed a caravan thieve?

[The Architect Of Fate]

This popular nonsense arises from a basic confusion between the Arabic words idtajaa' and dajaa' , the first one simply meaning to lie somewhere, while the other means intercourse, which isn't mentioned anywhere in the... not very authentic hadith .The hadith reporting that has a very weak chain of narrators, it's not authentic at all. Even if it was, it would simply mean Muhammad' lied on someone's grave to remind himself of death and resurrection.

So first you claim that there's nothing bad in Hadiths but that some people don't know how to read them,  and then you dismiss Hadiths as not authentic and non reliable. So again you are being dishonest and contradict yourself. The only person you are lying to is yourself.

It's invalid because he and his "scholars" don't like it

It's mistranslated because he and his "scholars" don't like it


All he can do is call you ignorant because he can quote some apologist talking point lol

And his babble about how the books came about is irrelevant.

I love how when one of his points gets knocked down his response is either to call you ignorant or jump to another failed or irrelevant point

You can't compel a rock to speak or religious zealot to change .