A murderer is free to murder. That is why it happens all the time. The question you are trying to ask is whether he should be punished for it, which is not relevant to this conversation. This conversation is dealing with whether he should have the choice to do it to begin with. The answer to that question is yes and not only because it is impossible to stop all crime.
Obviously not, lucent. My life is evidence of that. I know what is best for me. I do not always get it, but I work hard at it. I am the one doing the work here. If god knew what was good for me, he would make sure I get it, which he doesn't. No, if he did exist, according to your book, he would not only make my life more difficult than necessary, but also take away everything I love in life once I hit heaven, assuming he didn't torture me for all of eternity.
Obviously not, lucent. My life is evidence of that. I know what is best for me. I do not always get it, but I work hard at it. I am the one doing the work here. If god knew what was good for me, he would make sure I get it, which he doesn't. No, if he did exist, according to your book, he would not only make my life more difficult than necessary, but also take away everything I love in life once I hit heaven, assuming he didn't torture me for all of eternity.
