The Atheist Forums Playlist

[Ranjr]

Sounds like he was air guitaring the original track. Love the song though.

The difference between the two, is you could tell that the Frida cover was a guy really trying to play along. This sounds like he simply played the original track without his own guitar playing in with it. In other words "too perfect".

In both cases the "perfect" album quality cannot be found even in a live concert. Look at where this guy is allegedly playing. Not a sound studio, but his own bedroom. You are not going to get that quality that you are allegedly claiming here in this video in a non studio environment. This guy was merely mimicking the song on a real studio track. 

My guy playing the Frida cover was real, so of course it isn't going to be perfect.

Wrong.  The kid is playing live, recording direct to sound card, probably through an effects pedal.  The way I've done it many times.  The original Rhoads track is muted or cancelled.  Look at the equipment on his desk.  You're talking to musicians here.  You know that, right?  It's a good chance to learn, so get over your silly notions.

The guy playing to Frida is sloppily playing along with the chord progression.  He doesn't even have a go at the solo.  He sucks.