(November 16, 2011 at 12:17 am)toro Wrote: The former implies the later. Possible means it could be true and it could be false. Otherwise it's called 'true'/'false'. If you define it as true/false, you're begging the question.
Well stating it could be true, doesn't necessarily state it could be false. I disagree with this. Possible simple means it could be, it doesn't mean it could possible not be
Quote:God being possible in a possible world means: we can premise that God exists in a possible (your second term) world, and we can premise that God does not exist in a possible (your second term) world. Both premises are possible (your first term).
No it doesn't mean we can premise God not existing in a world. Both premises are not shown to be possible. We don't know whether a world can exist without God. If God is a Necessary Being and exists, then a world cannot exist without God.
