(July 23, 2022 at 12:03 pm)BrianSoddingBoru4 Wrote:"If a supernatural being fine-tuned the universe for human life, why can't I survive in a geothermal vent, or under six tonnes of gravel?"(July 23, 2022 at 9:48 am)Billy Bob Wrote: "Given that there are terrestrial environs where humans can't survive (at least not without very special help), it's mighty hard to make the case that even the Earth is finely tuned for human life."
Says the person who is alive on this earth.
Yes, I'm alive on this Earth, but they are more places on this Earth where I can't survive unaided than places where I can.
If a supernatural being fine-tuned the universe for human life, why can't I survive in a geothermal vent, or under six tonnes of gravel? Why is it that I have to breathe a mixture of nitrogen/oxygen and not sulfur dioxide? Why do I need supplemental oxygen to ascend to great heights or descend to great depths? Why can't I thrive in conditions where polar bears or tardigrades seem to make a good living?
The most - the very most - you can claim is that a very, very narrow range of living conditions have been fine-tuned for human beings. And even that claim is more than a little specious, since evolutionary theory has already answered it.
You're very stupid.
Boru
Look, go be stupid with someone else. If that is your standard for saying the earth is not suitable for life, then so be it. I'm not going to your low standard of making that stupid comment. From the same joke who also can't take things in order that we first needed a universe. So you skip to fine-tuning and make this stooooooo-pid comment...
"If a supernatural being fine-tuned the universe for human life, why can't I survive in a geothermal vent, or under six tonnes of gravel?"
The big laugh is from the title of this topic, as if you fools take science seriously.
One more time for absurdness.....
"If a supernatural being fine-tuned the universe for human life, why can't I survive in a geothermal vent, or under six tonnes of gravel?"
