Islam owns atheism with a single verse

[Astreja]

I'm fine with my perspective being subjective.  Everyone's perspective is subjective. 

Right. That's why moral judgments shouldn't rely on anybody's perspective, including yours.

Or Mohammed's, or Allah's perspective either. Just as subjective as my perspective.

In such a case I would rather see justice not done. 

And there, we have it. You're prepared to argue for injustice just to escape your doomed argument: about finite crimes necessarily requiring finite punishment.

One criminal dying a natural death is infinitely more moral and just than torturing the criminal for eternity. I find all hell-focused religions, and their deities, to be utterly abhorrent.