(June 11, 2012 at 10:27 pm)Brian37 Wrote: "Mind" is a word and a bullshit woo word that implies there is something separate from the brain and makes magic out of about mundane organ functions.
You also have to have a brain to make up a word, like snarfwidget, or googgoledgop, but the ability to make shit up is hardly impressive.
Saying "There is no mind" only requires a brain to think with, just like saying there is no god doesn't require a god to believe in.
Now others in this thread have made the argument and no one has refuted it. If one's brains get scrambled by a bullet, or if one's head gets decapitated the the structure is no longer in tact to manifest the display of outward expression you falsely call "mind". There is only the brain and the brain in motion, there is no such thing as a "mind".
I am sorry if that is not sexy enough.
What is so scary about merely being a product of evolution? The brain is an amazing organ and there certainly are lots of interesting historical figures and interesting people in the world today, but I am not going to pretend that "me" is something special outside my own material brain.
I am a product of evolution, genetics, chemical makeup, information input and my brain in motion, but that is it.
You are fuck all nuts. I went out of my way to explain to the author of the OP how emergence theory didn't work, pointing out that a proponent of strong emergent theory still holds a monist position. No reasonable person, saving you of course, thinks that the mind exists outside the brain as a mere woo word.