(July 6, 2012 at 1:01 pm)CliveStaples Wrote: Okay, to stop getting bogged down in referencing past portions of the argument, I'm just going to wipe the slate clean.
Is the following belief system atheistic? If not, why not?
{"Justin Bieber exists", "Hurting people is wrong", "Honda is a good car manufacturer"}
Note that I'm not asking if any of these beliefs are accurate, or true.
Here's my thinking:
Yes, the belief system is atheistic; it doesn't include (or imply) the belief "At least one god exists".
Rhythm, do you agree with my evaluation of the belief system? Or do you think that I've made a mistake?
The three statements are NOT A BELIEF SYSTEM. When are you going to drop thid stupid semantic prestidigitation?