Why aren't you a Christian?

[Mystic]

Unfortunately, the same is true for your boy.

I disagree. One proof, is that if Quran was all made up by people after Prophet Mohammad and Prophet Mohammad was made up, we would've read about all sorts of miracles like we find in the hadiths, in Quran. Like we find in the Bible.

Instead there is all sorts of red herrings avoiding why a sign is not sent with the Prophet and finally an answer that doesn't make any sense: that the only reason for not sending a sign is due to former people rejecting them in the past.

I know there was the moon miracle, but why write about that miracle, and write many verses about the objection of why not being sent with a sign with red herrings. In fact, it's possible the moon miracle was added later...but I don't think the the repeated mention about why he wasn't sent with signs would've been added later.

If it was people making it up, they would've stayed consistent with the stories of the Prophets and miracles, and miracles with the last Prophet. But this was a major problem the Prophet Mohammad faced. He spoke about Prophets in the past and they were sent with miracles, and so people objected, why aren't we sent with a sign like the people in the past were sent signs?

Why would people making up the whole story come up with such a problem and inconsistency?