Theory number 3.

[Mystic]

Is there a significant gap?

I think it's rational to incline to that idea.

Could, perhaps, a 'non-concious' entity evolve into an entity that is only vaguely aware of its surroundings?

By means of naturalism, it seems to be not the case, right now to me.

It all depends on what conscious is deemed to be; how well integrated must the senses of an organism be to call it conscious?

Whatever level of consciousness it has, there is a significant gap between non-consciousness.

It is difficult to draw a line between a human and an ape, but we know that humans are different from lower primates.

Yeah but in this case, there is can be perpetual change. There doesn't have to be a step between a human and a primate. There is gradual change and we can't even put a line. But the same is not true of consciousness and unconsciousness. Whatever level of consciousness exist as weak as it maybe, it's significantly different from non-conscious.

We also know that this transition occured solely becasue of evolution.

This is news to me. Evolution is a theory, not a certain knowledge.

We also know that the non-conscious entities evolved into conscious ones (unless you are a creationist).

I don't have to be a creationist. To be a creationist, it means I claim to believe evolution didn't happen. I don't have to be evolutionist, because it doesn't seem to be conclusive to me. I don't even have to believe evolution can possibly explain life, let alone, that it does, to not be a creationist.

And the truth right now, my agnosticism is a total state of confusion. I don't know that I don't know type confusion.

It's not the type that asserts I am unconvinced by evidence that there is no higher power neither is it the type that claims I cannot know or that I do not know deep inside.

I am "confused" .

So, what does this tell us, then? (not rhetorical)

We put faith in authorities too much I don't have to believe in evolution to justify my lack of belief in God or a Creator. I can be agnostic, and think there is strong arguments for a Creator, just that I don't feel confidence in arguments anymore.

I think the best word to describe by position is "confused".