RE: Without citing the bible, what marks the bible as the one book with God's message?
January 4, 2013 at 12:36 am
(This post was last modified: January 4, 2013 at 12:36 am by Drich.)
(January 2, 2013 at 3:32 pm)whateverist Wrote: I've heard of lots of scholarship being done to establish the existence of persons with the right names inhabiting the right places at the right times. But lets cut to the chase. Suppose there was a Mary and a Jesus and a Paul and Sneezy and Rudolph and whoever else the bibles says is part of its story. Lets go ahead and grant you that the stuff the bible says happened is right too - within reason. I can't grant you a talking snake, God speaking from a burning bush, a man living in a whale, a resurrection, a flood covering Mt. Everest, the story of creation or anything else that suggests the supernatural. But I will grant, for the sake of argument, that every natural event described in the bible is historically accurate.Because te bible is the road map to obtain the 'proof of God" He has left for us. The bible in of itself is not proof of God, it just the instructions on how to find it.
Given that, why should anyone believe the bible is the word of a supernatural god? Why should anyone think its god exists at all?
Quote:Okay Christians, again only for the sake of argument, lets suppose that god does exist and the bible records an attempt on its part to communicate with mankind. How do you justify a literal reading of the bible? Perhaps a poetic reading was intended, not by the scribes, but by your god. If this god of yours is as ineffable and other worldly as is claimed, why would you think that such a being could communicate with beings as limited as ourselves in any way other than parables and poetry. You may really be missing the whole message by concretizing the poetic.The reason we have been given "parables and poetry" in contrast to an absolute or definitive texts is so we do not worship the text itself. In otherwords so we do not worship the method of worship as the Jews did when they were give God's absolutes.
Quote:Remember Christians, the challenge is to justify 1) that the bible is the special book and 2) that a literal interpretation is the one intended by your god .. without (for obvious reasons) citing the bible itself. I await your guidance.Then seek the guidance of the Holy Spirit. after all it is a relationship with the Holy Spirit that the whole of the bible points to.
