Skyrim's been out a while.

[thesummerqueen]

I think the questline was epic, but the end quest rewards kinda suck in comparison.

I didn't find much point in it or excitement until the end with the fire and everything. The Jester and the Night Mother portion both irritated and squicked me out.

The initiate recruits are bland, and frankly pointless.

Didn't get past rebuilding the sanctuary to find that out.

Nazir should have been recruitable and marryable (I just invented a new word!).

Now THERE was an NPC with a personality.

Essentially they should of done more to make you feel like the guild was growing, and that you are in charge of it. Kinda more like the thieves guild, even though that isn't perfect.

This is a problem with most of the places you're made leader of, I think. I felt like they could have programmed a bit more into the Thieves Guild and the Mages College to make you feel like you accomplished something.