Intelligent Design, Proof IV

[Muslim Scholar]

The word itself is irrelevant, I mean a non-planned event
Accident, coincidence, by-chance they are the same

Except that natural selection is what guides the process; there's nothing accidental about this. You are being blatantly dishonest to try and puff up a point you can't directly demonstrate in any way, and I for one am not going to allow you to get away with it.

In this case, YES
It will be circular logic for the first cell to come by a coincidence
As the minimum system required must pre exist and coordinate before existence.

That's a quibble with abiogenesis, not evolution. They're different things. More than that, ever heard of the Miller Yurey experiment?

Who said evolution? I didn't say that
Abiogenesis is just a sophisticated, misleading term for coincidence
If it is possible why don't you repeat it!!!

---

As the minimum system required must pre exist and coordinate before existence.

Have you demonstrated that this is impossible, or cannot ever happen by circumstance?

this is what I just said!
For a coincidence there must be a logical possible sequence that can arise from a coincidence, which is impossible.