RE: Why I Am Pro-Life
July 25, 2013 at 4:29 pm
(This post was last modified: July 25, 2013 at 4:29 pm by Tea Earl Grey Hot.)
(July 25, 2013 at 4:20 pm)fr0d0 Wrote: Hey teg
The first line breaks the scientific observation though: that a zygote is a human life.
That's irrelevant because this argument doesn't rely on whether something is human or not. The argument doesn't assume " if it's human, it has a right to life." The argument effectively states that if it's not self aware and if it can't desire "continued existence", then it doesn't have a right to life. You can apply this argument to any number of things.
See:
All beings with a right to life are capable of desiring continued existence.
All beings capable of desiring continued existence have a concept of themselves as a continuing subject of experiences.
No plant has a concept of itself as a continuing subject of experiences.
Therefore, No plant has a right to life.
or
All beings with a right to life are capable of desiring continued existence.
All beings capable of desiring continued existence have a concept of themselves as a continuing subject of experiences.
No computer has a concept of itself as a continuing subject of experiences.
Therefore, No computer has a right to life.
or
All beings with a right to life are capable of desiring continued existence.
All beings capable of desiring continued existence have a concept of themselves as a continuing subject of experiences.
No rock has a concept of itself as a continuing subject of experiences.
Therefore, No rock has a right to life.


