A small thanks to the resident Theists..

[Airyaman]

Find me an atheist who believes in Jesus-as-deity-incarnate. I won't hold my breath.

There certainly are atheists who accept Jesus-as-preacher, without all the supernatural baggage. You may as well debate the historicity of Tony Stark without Iron Man.

Then it's incorrect to interpret the passage as referring to atheists, and catfish's point stands. You can't have it both ways.

Are you a Christian who does not understand what "Christ" means? (Hint: it wasn't his last name).