Who cares. This argument only applies to an omni-benevolent god, which is only believed in by a fairly small minority of the theists that have ever existed. I don't believe in any God not just an omni-benevolent on. So why make such a shallow argument. The problem of evil (and this fairly uncreative variation) is the weakest argument that atheists have because of this and I wish it would stop being beaten into the ground.


