(May 19, 2015 at 8:11 pm)nicanica123 Wrote: Im still waiting for your response from my last claim that you straw manned me
I already addressed that so you can keep waiting. I maintain that my summation of your misrepresentation of Dillahunty's talk juxtaposed with your stated reason for giving up the ghost is accurate; therefore, can in no way be considered an extreme position and in turn is not an example of a straw man argument. Your cry of straw man comes across as a reflexive retort some give when they are uncomfortable with a conclusion and carries as much weight as claims of god with no evidence. If, in the other thread, you actually care to explain why my argument is a straw man then we can continue the conversation. All you have done is to make the claim, which I rebutted by citing what Dillahunty actually claims in the video and reiterating your own reason for becoming an atheist. You then simply restated your claim and began a sequence of 'is so/is not' argumentation. I'm not sure what you expect at that point.
