Ask a Catholic

[Mr.wizard]

Randy quote

"All of humanity is the result of previous rapes at some time or another.  So if there had never been any rapes chances are we would never exist.  We are here now because our ancestors were the rapers and the raped.  If there was never another rape from this second on that would still be true for the people in the distant future. "

So your saying rape is good? It was all part of god's plan, so you finally admit your god condones rape?

That was my comment, not Randy's.  What I'm saying is that we exist because of what other people did, good or bad.  If we think that some behaviors are despicable we may refrain from doing them ourselves but countless other people did them in the past, so we exist as a result of their actions.  Was it a good thing that one of your distant maternal ancestors was raped and had a child whose descendants resulted in you and your children?  If you could go back in time and save her from being raped would you even though it means that your mother or father and you and your children and grandchildren would never exist?  Or would you let her get raped so that you could all exist?

First let me say SORRY RANDY, I misquoted you!!!!

Well your asking me to choose between one rape and the entire extinction of my bloodline, this is hardly the dilemma an all knowing all powerful god would of encountered.