RE: Islam; my faith; and other faiths
April 25, 2017 at 6:59 pm
(This post was last modified: April 25, 2017 at 7:05 pm by WinterHold.)
The Hadith's main complex resides not just in its content; but also in the statements of its writers.
For example, Al Bukhari ( which his Hadith compiling is recognized by all Sunni Muslims to be authentic and true in terms of dating back to the prophet ), he has rejected many Islamic paths and teachings in his time:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_a...dith_works
Also; this link provides reasons to consider rejecting Hadiths:
https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Bukhari-an...ollections
Now; I present my case.
If Bukhari himself rejected teachings and other writing, and his publications contain weak and unreliable sources (according to some famous scholars like [url=https://islamqa.info/en/178907]Al-Albani , then why am I criticized harshly for abandoning the Hadith?
It cannot be trusted. Shiites and Sunnies should grow up and learn the manors of history compiling; if you asked me. Blowing up mosques and markets, and stabbing artists in the street in response to the way people differed in their view toward historiHcal text, is just barbaric and unethical.
Personally; I find the Quran more clear. The oldest version of the Quran matches the recorded era of prophet Mohammed, and the two pages match the Quran we have now:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birmingham...manuscript
I would hold on to those two leaves, that identically match the current ones; along with their carbon dating, more than I will hold to a Hadith book.
It's clear: I like to trust stuff. Things that cannot be trusted annoy me in terms of faith.
About the menstruating. If it's impossible for females not to menstruate under any cause, then you have a case; Crunchy.
But there is already a medical condition that prevents some women from menstruating:
http://www.steadyhealth.com/topics/25-ye...wrong-with
http://youngwomenshealth.org/2013/06/12/amenorrhea/
http://ehealthforum.com/health/i-am-and-never-had-a-period-t270621.html
Why did your mind go to pedophilia ?
Doesn't that mean, that you may be loaded with right wing propaganda about Islam before searching?
Some women grow up and don't have the period. But they can love and get married.
For example, Al Bukhari ( which his Hadith compiling is recognized by all Sunni Muslims to be authentic and true in terms of dating back to the prophet ), he has rejected many Islamic paths and teachings in his time:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_a...dith_works
Quote:given the fact that Bukhari rejected qiyas and other forms of ra'y completely.[15] Bukhari's positions have even been compared to those of Ibn Hazm.[16][/url]
Also; this link provides reasons to consider rejecting Hadiths:
https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Bukhari-an...ollections
Now; I present my case.
If Bukhari himself rejected teachings and other writing, and his publications contain weak and unreliable sources (according to some famous scholars like [url=https://islamqa.info/en/178907]Al-Albani , then why am I criticized harshly for abandoning the Hadith?
It cannot be trusted. Shiites and Sunnies should grow up and learn the manors of history compiling; if you asked me. Blowing up mosques and markets, and stabbing artists in the street in response to the way people differed in their view toward historiHcal text, is just barbaric and unethical.
Personally; I find the Quran more clear. The oldest version of the Quran matches the recorded era of prophet Mohammed, and the two pages match the Quran we have now:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birmingham...manuscript
I would hold on to those two leaves, that identically match the current ones; along with their carbon dating, more than I will hold to a Hadith book.
It's clear: I like to trust stuff. Things that cannot be trusted annoy me in terms of faith.
About the menstruating. If it's impossible for females not to menstruate under any cause, then you have a case; Crunchy.
But there is already a medical condition that prevents some women from menstruating:
http://www.steadyhealth.com/topics/25-ye...wrong-with
http://youngwomenshealth.org/2013/06/12/amenorrhea/
http://ehealthforum.com/health/i-am-and-never-had-a-period-t270621.html
Why did your mind go to pedophilia ?
Doesn't that mean, that you may be loaded with right wing propaganda about Islam before searching?
Some women grow up and don't have the period. But they can love and get married.