(September 23, 2019 at 9:47 pm)Jehanne Wrote: From your so-called immaterial soul to your brain to your finger to the middle C chord on the piano, please explain why the piano resonated with a middle C frequency, but, as modern Science has explained the brain to piano resonating part, just do the immaterial soul to brain part. That's what I am really after here.
I understand that mind is at the beginning of the chain of events that make the piano note. I understand that mind exists in the presence of electrochemical events in the brain.
I can't explain how the immaterial soul caused the piano to play, according to your definition of "soul," because I don't think you have defined "soul" at all yet.
How is "soul" different from "mind"? How is it different from "spirit," if such a thing as "spirit energy" exists, as the blog post says?
Tell me how mind and soul are different, and I may be able to answer your question. Or do you assert that they are always the same? How do you know this?
You continue to speak as if soul has a mind, or as if soul is the same as mind. Unless you clarify your definitions, you're not telling me anything about soul at all.