RE: Is Islam A Death Cult?
April 9, 2023 at 10:29 am
(This post was last modified: April 9, 2023 at 10:31 am by Leonardo17.)
(April 2, 2023 at 2:33 pm)Ferrocyanide Wrote:(April 1, 2023 at 5:07 am)Goosebump Wrote: In the Quran and hadith, martyrs are first and foremost those who have died in jihad, “fighting in the path of God,” those who have perished violently in battle.
Certainly, death in battle is not the only way to achieve martyrdom in Islam. Those who die unjustly or whose lives are truncated by some act of God are martyrs as well. Someone who is killed for their money, someone who drowns, someone who dies building a mosque or in a structural collapse, a woman who dies in childbirth, the victims of a plague, someone who is killed defending their family, someone who is killed for speaking truth to an unjust ruler, who dies in prison or who stands alone for truth in corrupted times; even (according to one hadith) someone who falls in love and represses their desire with fatal consequences—all these are martyrs.
Source: (https://tinyurl.com/3xtv3b39)
In the article he goes on to take a very erudite and western interpretation of the Quran and the meaning of Duty.
"What if Muslims restored this idea of ‘bearing witness’ to the word martyrdom? What if we thought of martyrdom as bearing witness by being willing to die in the name of that God Who tells us that saving one life is like saving all of humanity, that standing up to injustice is the highest act of faith, that feeding the stranger and the orphan, and sheltering the wayfarer are the solemn duties of every individual? The Quran (41:33) tells us, “What better word is there than calling out to God, doing a good deed and saying, Indeed I am one of those who submits to God.”"
It's always a good idea to go over definitions:
What's a death cult?
Do you mean a religion/cult that encourages members to go to battle when some leader decides to go to battle, because a neighboring country has resources, is not part of the islamic faith, or maybe they want to settle a justice related issue outside of the courthouse?
And at the same time, the religion/cult tells the followers not to worry about dying bc the god will give them benefits in the afterlife (people will remember him as a martyr, which is a badge of honor)?
Quote:"What if Muslims restored this idea of ‘bearing witness’ to the word martyrdom?
Bearing witness to a word? What does that even mean?
There is a more in debt way of looking to these issues. This way of looking exists. But its superficial. Or at least it’s not of benefit to me. SO I don’t see things that way.
2) To me it means that you are willing to be just and truthful. That you don’t simply bow down to anyone simply because he / she / they seem to be more powerful than you. Again: this is a spiritual principle that is present in many real religious teachings