Stump the Christian?

[FatAndFaithless]

Really? Just gonna slap the Kalam on the end of that post as if its legitimate or convincing at all?

[Longhorn]

oh sure, more Kalam. it's not like it's been done ad nauseam or anything

[Ravenshire]

Everything that begins has a cause. The universe obviously began. So, the universe has a cause.

What was it?

Everything that begins has a cause. Gawd obviously began. So, gawd has a cause.

What was it?

Or, are you going to resort to special pleading.

[Randy Carson]

And btw, when you start that nonsense, I know you have nothing.

When you have to twist the words of others to make you're point, everyone knows you have nothing.

What existed prior to the Big Bang, SOW?

No one knows, including you. That's why your question is nonsensical.

But science provides the answers to everything...so, a question that science cannot answer is a nonsensical question.

If science is all-powerful, can it make a rock so big that even it can't lift it?

---

Really?  Just gonna slap the Kalam on the end of that post as if its legitimate or convincing at all?

oh sure, more Kalam. it's not like it's been done ad nauseam or anything

Oh, good.

You've done this before. 

That means the two of you should be able to provide really clear, concise refutations.

Please do.

---

Everything that begins has a cause. The universe obviously began. So, the universe has a cause.

What was it?

Everything that begins has a cause. Gawd obviously began. So, gawd has a cause.

What was it?

Or, are you going to resort to special pleading.

Obviously. 

But one question: What is your evidence for your claim that God began?

[Ravenshire]

When you have to twist the words of others to make you're point, everyone knows you have nothing.


No one knows, including you. That's why your question is nonsensical.

But science provides the answers to everything...so, a question that science cannot answer is a nonsensical question.

If science is all-powerful, can it make a rock so big that even it can't lift it?

[Ravenshire]

But one question: What is your evidence for your claim that God began?

What is your evidence the universe did?

[Longhorn]

oh sure, more Kalam. it's not like it's been done ad nauseam or anything

Oh, good.

You've done this before. 

That means the two of you should be able to provide really clear, concise refutations.

Please do.

composition fallacy, fallacy of equivocation and general idiocy, for starters

a quick search on the forums alone would've told you that and much more.

[Esquilax]

I'm personally okay with evolution. I think God used it to get us to where we are today.

Oh, so once in a blue moon you can recognize a fact when it slaps you in the face; you just decided to ruin it at the end there.

I'm just wondering why anything at all exists if there was a "time" in which nothing at all existed except a "singularity" (whatever that is).

Why did the singularity change from being a singularity to being the universe?

When an object moves, we assume a cause of the motion, don't we?

Everything that begins has a cause. The universe obviously began. So, the universe has a cause.

What was it?

If I answer "we don't know yet," which is the truthful response that everyone should be making, are you just going to go "aha!" and say therefore god?

[Jenny A]

But science provides the answers to everything...so, a question that science cannot answer is a nonsensical question.

If science is all-powerful, can it make a rock so big that even it can't lift it?

Science is a set of very successful methods for determining the truth about the real world. Scientists have made great progress using the scientific method both in understanding and technology. But scientists have not answered all questions and there are questions they will never answer. And it is better to know that you do not have an answer than to pretend that you do.

[Randy Carson]

But one question: What is your evidence for your claim that God began?

What is your evidence the universe did?

Is the universe infinite?

What is a singularity?

Was all matter compressed into a space smaller than the size of a sub-atomic particle?

What caused it to change?

---

Oh, good.

You've done this before. 

That means the two of you should be able to provide really clear, concise refutations.

Please do.

composition fallacy, fallacy of equivocation and general idiocy, for starters

a quick search on the forums alone would've told you that and much more.

Oh, general idiocy.

Yeah, I overlooked that. Never mind. 

---

But science provides the answers to everything...so, a question that science cannot answer is a nonsensical question.

If science is all-powerful, can it make a rock so big that even it can't lift it?

Science is a set of very successful methods for determining the truth about the real world.  Scientists have made great progress using the scientific method both in understanding and technology.  But scientists have not answered all questions and there are questions they will never answer.  And it is better to know that you do not have an answer than to pretend that you do.

And it is your contention that Christians are pretending to have answers that they do not really have. 

Is it possible that they have a few to those questions that science will never answer?