Giants and the Square Cubed Law

[ReptilianPeon]

The hadiths say that Adam was 90 feet tall.

Not just Adam. Noah too is said to be huge. I hope someone will one day take an X-ray camera and photograph the various tombs in order to remind people that Noah didn't exist. Isn't it interesting how there are multiple tombs of Noah? They can't all have the right body, can they?

[paulpablo]

So according to the Square Cube Law, when the size of an object doubles, the surface area of something is increased by 4 times, and the volume (and mass) of something is increased by 8 times. 

Meaning that the literal interpretation of giants in the bible obviously couldn't exist. If a 6 foot 200 lb. human were to double his size and keep the same shape, he'd have 4 times the muscle power to move 8 times the weight. So, he would be 12 feet tall and weigh 1,600 pounds, and he'd have half his original strength to do it. And that's just doubling his size. Fundies are claiming that giants were far bigger than that, and that would just be impossible. They'd collapse under their own weight. This is why Hollywood style giant ants could never exist. If a human were to successfully grow that size, their legs and feet would have to look like that of an elephant's, and their spine and neck and everything else about them would have to be completely changed. By the time all the changes were made, they wouldn't look human.

So for any of the religious who might be reading this, is it time to re-evaluate your religious beliefs yet? Mathematics has just destroyed the fundie 'Murican literal interpretation. 

So instead of it being a 50 foot Paul Bunyan styled giant, could it be that because the average human back then was of a shorter height (about 5'6,) that when an occasional person did grow to 6 or maybe even 7 feet that they were considered giants? I don't know if there's ever been a human in that time period to grow to such heights, but it seems far more rational to me than just saying there were these mythological giants.

I'm pretty experienced with Islamic apologetics now, if I remember correctly the explanation to this is that the earth was smaller and therefore had less of a gravitational pull in the days of the early prophets.

There's probably a million things scientifically wrong with that explanation but that's the explanation I've come across before.

[ReptilianPeon]

I'm pretty experienced with Islamic apologetics now, if I remember correctly the explanation to this is that the earth was smaller and therefore had less of a gravitational pull in the days of the early prophets.

There's probably a million things scientifically wrong with that explanation but that's the explanation I've come across before.

A much better explanation would surely be to say that the bones were made of a different material to the bones of the humans of today and were therefore much stronger. But, of course, there's no evidence of these 'giants' ever having existed. Where are the skeletons, for example? If there was actually any evidence for these large humans, biologists would be talking about them.

[Alex K]

The hadiths say that Adam was 90 feet tall.

Not just Adam. Noah too is said to be huge. I hope someone will one day take an X-ray camera and photograph the various tombs in order to remind people that Noah didn't exist. Isn't it interesting how there are multiple tombs of Noah? They can't all have the right body, can they?

Schrödinger's tomb?

[Wyrd of Gawd]

Imagine the crap piles 90 feet tall people would leave behind.