We don't belong here.

[Deesse23]

Having "nothing natural to survive earth" does not refer to "earth itself"; it refers to "ourselves".
In other words; you have no natural mechanism in your own body that ensures the production of food, drink and air.

Wrong

The major natural source of the vitamin is synthesis of cholecalciferol in the skin from cholesterol through a chemical reaction that is dependent on sun exposure (specifically UVB radiation)

[Cod]

I suppose we belong in a place with rivers of milk, and maidens with jewels for hair then do we?

[Angrboda]

You've concluded that a thing being unnatural is bad, and therefore that our existing on earth is bad because it's unnatural. The flaw is in your initial assumption that if a thing is unnatural it is necessarily bad. There are many unnatural things that are actually good (let me count the ways). So the problem with your argument has nothing to do with whether our survival on earth is natural or not, but rather your assumption that if it is not natural it is bad. Once you remove the flawed assumption, your argument collapses.

[brewer]

If you don't belong please get the fuck out! This world is mine.

[LastPoet]

You've concluded that a thing being unnatural is bad, and therefore that our existing on earth is bad because it's unnatural.  The flaw is in your initial assumption that if a thing is unnatural it is necessarily bad.  There are many unnatural things that are actually good (let me count the ways).  So the problem with your argument has nothing to do with whether our survival on earth is natural or not, but rather your assumption that if it is not natural it is bad.  Once you remove the flawed assumption, your argument collapses.

I might be wrong on all philosobabble sold ideas, But anything that happens is quite natural.

This is a distinction never made. How do you go about determining natural from unnatural? What is the criteria?

[The Grand Nudger]

"Unnatural" is a conceptual disctinion...people who think that all things are ultimately natural still find use for the term to describe one set of natural™ things not like the other™.

Consider artificial vs natural selection.  Both are natural, ultimately...but we employ the term to signify that one is not like the other.

The trouble, for atlass, at least..is that he completely failed to note any thing that was unlike the other™.

[LastPoet]

I suppose we belong in a place with rivers of milk, and maidens with jewels for hair then do we?

i would settle for a personality and a nice pair of tits, but anyone can have preferences of their own.

[Rhizomorph13]

I suppose we belong in a place with rivers of milk, and maidens with jewels for hair then do we?

i would settle for a personality and a nice pair of tits, but anyone can have preferences of their own.

Just remember this, the land of milk and honey is also the land of cow shit and bee stings!

[Gwaithmir]

1-To survive the cold, we wear "the hide of other creatures" that  already exist on earth.

No. We wear clothes to be comfortable. Personally I enjoy a naked hike in the mountains in the wind and rain.

Um....any photos?

[ohreally]

What are the natural conditions that allow go to survive? (besides people)

Is there something that survives that doesn't need other things to keep surviving?


Congrats on another idea that makes theism look stupid.