Bombay High Court Rules Astrology To Be a Science

[Jaysyn]

Bombay High Court Rules Astrology To Be a Science

It looks like the USA / UK / Australia aren't the only countries with uneducated morons in positions of power.

[thesummerqueen]

You know what's funny? Just last week I was at lunch with our plant manager, an engineer who went to Clemson University, and he is Indian. He said the pressure Indian families put on their children to go into prestigious "smart" jobs (such as engineer, doctor, architect, etc) is immense - as is the pressure to do well in school. You would think with such an emphasis on education, more people would be against this sort of nonsense.

[Minimalist]

I think those idiots have their turbans tied to tightly.

[Anomalocaris]

You know what's funny? Just last week I was at lunch with our plant manager, an engineer who went to Clemson University, and he is Indian. He said the pressure Indian families put on their children to go into prestigious "smart" jobs (such as engineer, doctor, architect, etc) is immense - as is the pressure to do well in school. You would think with such an emphasis on education, more people would be against this sort of nonsense.

I noticed some Indian and Chinese educated scientists and engineers treat science as a skill to be mastered for a career, not a philosophical approach to truth finding to be adopted. It is as if science is analogous to accounting, only the bag of tricks and the body of rules to be mastered is much greater and move involved in science than in accounting. To them, adopting the sceintific approach seems to fundamentally be a career development measure rather than an act of self-enlightenment. They may learn these tricks and know those rules exceedingly well, and is able to excel on a day-to-day basis in a scientific establishment. They may become outstanding Romans while in Rome. But They often see no conflict between what they do for their day job, where they may do highly proficient and respected scientific work, and the attitude they take outside work, which may be distinctly superstitious and irrational. I knew one Chinese educated physics professor who is well respected in her field during the day, and a devotee of what I can only describe as a moronic homeopathic meditation cult at night. When she developed treatable breast cancer she rejected modern medicine and resorted to her healing meditation. She died from her treatable but untreated cancer.

[thesummerqueen]

Perhaps I just see a disconnect where someone is able to take what happens in their work day and throw it out and be someone different at home. If you're using some principles at work, how do you not go home and think "wait a minute..."

[shrugs] I've never been able to not be the same person thinking and personality-wise in work/school/home/internet, so what do I know? Maybe other people have better compartmentalizing abilities and therefore they shut off the processing part behind closed doors.

Of course, I guess the important thing to remember is that those who make the laws...aren't necessarily science-educated. Something I as an American should be QUITE familiar with.

[Anomalocaris]

Perhaps I just see a disconnect where someone is able to take what happens in their work day and throw it out and be someone different at home. If you're using some principles at work, how do you not go home and think "wait a minute..."

[shrugs] I've never been able to not be the same person thinking and personality-wise in work/school/home/internet, so what do I know? Maybe other people have better compartmentalizing abilities and therefore they shut off the processing part behind closed doors.

Of course, I guess the important thing to remember is that those who make the laws...aren't necessarily science-educated. Something I as an American should be QUITE familiar with.

I think it is an artifact of craming and rote learning practiced in the Chinese and maybe Indian educational systems. This system of learning create students who are exceptionally good as doing what it takes to beat the exames and excel performance reviews, but really does not spent time digesting the full implication of what they learned.

[thesummerqueen]

Darling, that happens in the US educational system as well. It's called "Standardized Testing" and it's already producing kids who can call out facts but who can't actually process.

[Minimalist]

American students are pretty weak on the facts, too.

http://www.theledger.com/article/2011013...se-Concern

[Zen Badger]

American students are pretty weak on the facts, too.

http://www.theledger.com/article/2011013...se-Concern

And while there continues to be an increasing call to teach creationism as a viable alternative to reality they will always struggle with science.

[Thor]

Astrology is such obvious crap that I can't believe anyone takes it seriously. What the hell does the position of a planet have to do with my personality or life?