Hi everyone! I'm new here
I'm a theology student from the Netherlands and believe in God (I'm a Christian). I've written an article exploring the question of the meaning of life from theistic and atheistic perspectives.
My central argument is that, without God, atheists cannot ultimately ground the meaning or value of human life, either in general or on an individual level. In other words, I argue that an atheistic worldview cannot provide an objective foundation for meaningfulness.
I'd be very interested to hear what you think. Would any of you be willing to read my article and offer a thoughtful critique of my argument? In particular, I'd appreciate hearing why you think my position is either tenable or untenable, and where you think my reasoning succeeds or fails.
I'm genuinely interested in engaging with opposing perspectives and learning from your feedback. (I'll also post this under the section for Atheists.)
Thanks in advance!
.
Why Atheism Offers No Satisfactory Account of Meaning in Life
.
Introduction
What is the meaning of life? What is the purpose of my existence? These questions are familiar not only to students and others who are still finding their way, but, in fact, to everyone. The search for meaning is therefore hardly an unfamiliar theme in contemporary society. Nor is the feeling that life is meaningless particularly new to us. Thinking deeply about these questions can lead to despair, yet avoiding them does not seem to be an option. Although meaning may seem an abstract concept, almost everyone has some view of what the meaning of life is, or might be. Some argue that we must create meaning for ourselves; others maintain that life is intrinsically valuable. So what makes a life meaningful?
What is the meaning of life? What is the purpose of my existence? These questions are familiar not only to students and others who are still finding their way, but, in fact, to everyone. The search for meaning is therefore hardly an unfamiliar theme in contemporary society. Nor is the feeling that life is meaningless particularly new to us. Thinking deeply about these questions can lead to despair, yet avoiding them does not seem to be an option. Although meaning may seem an abstract concept, almost everyone has some view of what the meaning of life is, or might be. Some argue that we must create meaning for ourselves; others maintain that life is intrinsically valuable. So what makes a life meaningful?
In an interview, the Dutch philosopher and atheist Herman Philipse argues that many religious believers mistakenly assume that life can acquire meaning only through faith. He then gives several examples of things from which people may derive meaning, such as friendships and hobbies like drawing. The perspective from which Philipse discusses meaning is striking, and differs from the way theists often approach the subject.
Recently, I read in The Oxford Handbook of Atheism that atheists and theists understand and speak about a ‘meaningful life’ in different ways. Atheists derive meaning in life from purposes within life, whereas theists derive meaning from the purpose of life as a whole. This is a sharp distinction, and it prompted me to think further. The handbook goes on to suggest that these perspectives involve different understandings of what makes life meaningful, and that neither atheists nor theists have a monopoly on the concept of a ‘meaningful life’. I strongly disagree with this last claim.
What Is Meaning?
When we speak of meaning, what exactly do we mean? In my view, meaning can exist in only two ways: (1) in relation to a purpose, or (2) in the good itself. When these two factors are objective, they confer value and make life meaningful. From a Christian perspective, for example, human life is intrinsically valuable because human beings are created in the image of God (cf. Gen. 9:6), and the purpose of our existence is ‘to glorify God’ (cf. 1 Cor. 10:31) ‘and to enjoy him for ever’ (Q&A 1, ‘Shorter Catechism’, in: The Westminster Standard). This is what makes life meaningful. Meaningful and valuable are therefore not synonyms, although they are closely related. The same is true of meaning and purpose.
An atheist understands meaning differently. After all, an atheist cannot speak of the ‘objective good’ in the same way as a theist. The atheist’s worldview contains no God who is the cause and purpose of everything, or who establishes the standard of what is good. On this account, an atheistic worldview cannot provide an objective foundation. To determine the value of something, one can only consider the nature of things and their origins. And when we consider the origin of life, we encounter a cosmos that is meaningless in itself and came into existence by chance.
The only way to make life meaningful, then, is for human beings to confer meaning upon it themselves. And, remarkably enough, that is precisely what they do. Of the two ways of understanding meaning outlined above, the atheist is left with the options that fit within this worldview: either meaning exists in relation to a purpose, or it does not. In the latter case, meaning is understood as existing without purpose.
The latter option may seem to undermine the very question of a meaningful life, but it does not necessarily do so. Nevertheless, I believe that it is ultimately an untenable position for the atheist. Let me briefly explain why. Many people, both atheists and theists, maintain that there are things that have no purpose but are nevertheless meaningful—for example, love. We do not ‘choose’ love because it is useful or serves some purpose, but because we desire it.
But why is love desirable? Why do we desire it? The answer must ultimately appeal to one of the two factors mentioned above: either love serves a purpose (perhaps because we seek companionship and connection), or we cannot explain precisely why we desire it but recognise that love is good in itself. Someone who says that love is not useful but is meaningful is using ‘meaningful’ as a synonym for ‘valuable’. For a theist, this presents no problem: within a theistic worldview, love can be good—and therefore valuable—in itself. This is not an option within an atheistic worldview. For the atheist, therefore, it is possible to speak of meaning only in relation to a purpose.
Returning to the point made in the introduction, for the atheist the meaning of life depends on the purposes pursued within life. This is why drawing, for example, can be regarded as a way of ‘giving meaning to life’. I assume that the purpose involved is implicitly connected with human happiness or well-being—for instance, the enjoyment or relaxation that drawing may provide. Yet this approach, according to which life becomes meaningful through the individual’s own act of conferring meaning upon it, still leaves us wondering what can or should count as meaningful.
Why should a life spent drawing be considered a meaningful life? Does the meaning of a life really depend entirely on an individual’s subjective experience? I doubt that this is what we are seeking when we ask the existential question, ‘What is the meaning of my life?’ Are we not, in fact, looking for something to hold on to—something that is true and valuable, and that shows us the direction in which we ought to move? Should meaning not rest on a firm, objective foundation, independent of our wandering subjective experience?
Our Purpose
Atheists seek to confer meaning on life by asking which things in life are meaningful. Yet in doing so, they cannot make life meaningful in itself. For that to be possible, life would have to be valuable in itself or have a valuable purpose—neither of which, I argue, an atheist can defend. The atheist therefore turns the matter around: meaning does not follow from the purpose of life; rather, it is created within life.
It is right, as The Oxford Handbook of Atheism does, to distinguish between the questions being asked. The question of ‘purposes within life’—what makes life feel worth living—is different from the question of ‘the value of life’, which concerns objectivity. These two questions call for different answers. But it is mistaken to claim that both perspectives provide a foundation for speaking of a ‘meaningful life’. Objective value is essential to meaning. The Christian worldview provides such a foundation and offers a clear account of what makes life meaningful. An atheistic worldview does not. If atheists also wish to speak of meaning in terms of objective value, they will therefore need to offer a different account.



