Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: November 18, 2026, 7:46 am

Thread Rating:
  • 1 Vote(s) - 1 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Natural Order and Science
RE: Natural Order and Science
(March 8, 2016 at 5:37 pm)Alex K Wrote:
(March 8, 2016 at 5:03 pm)little_monkey Wrote: Says the guy, YOU, who can't understand a basic definition that even a 5-year old would. Get a reality check.

You have such a compulsive need to display your superiority that you wouldn't recognize knowledge if it hit you in the head with a 4x4. It is literally impossible to discuss the subject with you because the only mode of communication your ego seems to allow is lecturing to an adoring audience. I don't even remember anymore what I asked you about your concept of virtual particles, but it doesn't matter because you keep saying the same three lines over and over again anyways.

you mean the same three lines you still don't understand, LOL. Ok smart guy, how do you embed particles into fields considering that a particle transforms under an irreducible unitary representations of the Poincare group, taking into account that for m=0, you have two states, and for m>0, there are 2J+1 states, where m is mass and J is spin? (hint: you get to learn that in the first few chapters of any QFT textbook, so it shouldn't be so hard for you to get to the answer). I await your response...
Reply
RE: Natural Order and Science
The fool hath said in his heart, There is a God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good.
Psalm 14, KJV revised edition

Reply
RE: Natural Order and Science
Reply
RE: Natural Order and Science
PHYSICS FIGHT!
Reply
RE: Natural Order and Science
(March 9, 2016 at 9:56 am)little_monkey Wrote: Most likely we will cross path again on this forum. I'll leave it up to you if you want to restart afresh or continue this hostility.

Sure, no problem. I'm not the vindictive type.

Anyway, about your definition of virtual particles Smile
Now that I know that you know this stuff well on a technical level, I can word my earlier question/remark more precisely.
Basically all the QFT lit I know treats the concept of "virtuality" of stable particles as the distance of the four momentum from the mass shell. I don't recall encountering a distinction between "real" and "virtual" particles based solely on whether they interact with an detector (which to me smells like mixing interpretations of QM, especially the arbitrary definition in copenhagen where the classical detector starts, and categories in QFT - something I am not used to), and if you could give me a reference i.e. to a textbook that does that, I would be grateful because it would be a new approach to the concept to me. I should have most of the known ones, but would be grateful if I didn't have to leaf through all of them searching for the right bits.

Don't you agree that even objects that in usual parlance would be called "real photons" - because they are emitted, have pretty much lightlike momentum and are registered at macroscopic distances from the source - can be described as a propagator between e.g. an electron in the source and an electron in the detector? (I think even Weinberg does that when talking about cluster decomposition, but I might confuse it with another book). This propagator interpreted as a Fourier transform to position space will contain momentum space propagators with all manner of off-shell four-momenta. Why do you still get a perfectly onshell photon in the S-Matrix element even if no photon ever registered is *purely and exactly* onshell? Precisely because we do a somewhat "unphysical" approximation by going to asymptotic times, right?

This lack of a sharp distinction and the somewhat artificial nature of the "real" in and out states was what I was trying to get at in order to dispel Harris' idea that there is this fundamental philosophical difference between real and virtual particles where one type really exists and the other is just a figment of theorists' imaginations.

Do you disagree?

p.s.
we are not even talking about loops here, which would open a whole new can of worms if we were to map the related physics to simple binary language like "real" and "virtual". But also here I think that the need to cancel soft real emission photons with loop corrections in Bloch-Nordsieck underlines the lack of a sharp philosophical ontological distinction between real and virtual particles. We are also not talking about unstable particles where the difference between on- and offshell is even muddier.

(March 9, 2016 at 9:56 am)little_monkey Wrote: You should have mentioned the Ward identities, but I'll forgive you.

I have mentioned gauge invariance and Gupta Bleuler conditions, that totes counts as a substitute for Ward identities! I have implicitly even mentioned Slavnov Taylor Smile
The fool hath said in his heart, There is a God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good.
Psalm 14, KJV revised edition

Reply
RE: Natural Order and Science
And then my eyes glazed back over....
[Image: extraordinarywoo-sig.jpg?rlkey=x1nmxbwrp...pouidnfvtl]
Reply
RE: Natural Order and Science
Quote:Anyway, about your definition of virtual particles


I don't remember exactly where I got this notion but I believe it was in Anthony Zee' s QFT IN A NUTSHELL, where he makes the following suggestion - I have put it in one of my earlier post, maybe not to you. He says you can look at the interaction between two electrons from afar,and what you conclude is an electrical repulsive force, or from QFT, it's an exchange of virtual particles. Then he asked, what about when you have opposite charges, do you get an attraction? So in redoing the calculation for the Feynman propagator, he gets an opposite sign, suggesting as in classical physics, you have an attractive force. I think that it was in that book he makes the plead that virtual are just as real as the ones that would hit your eyes. But I went through that book a long time ago. So maybe my thinking about these things have evolved since then. And so my thinking is a hodge-podge of all my readings and my own reflections. Regardless, I made that claim in one of my blogs (http://soi.blogspot.ca/2015/09/superposi...tates.html).

NOTE: Now my blogs have been designed to answer specific questions I often had from students, former students and acquaintances of students/former students. So they are not in any order, some are more elaborate than others, done at different levels of who I had in mind. They are pedagogical tools, not me bragging about my skills...;-)
Reply
RE: Natural Order and Science
Zee's book is interesting, unconventional and full of anecdotes and inside information. I had it on my desk not too long ago, but had ro return it before I could really look at it in detail. I plan to get it though.
The fool hath said in his heart, There is a God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good.
Psalm 14, KJV revised edition

Reply
RE: Natural Order and Science
(March 8, 2016 at 7:40 am)Alex K Wrote:
(March 8, 2016 at 7:28 am)Harris Wrote: All that said, I am firm on my argument that virtual particles are not particles at all.

Did you actually make an argument yourself somewhere in there?

Although, I have made my point clear but unfortunately because of my little carelessness you dudes had a chance to mess things up. Anyway, that would not stop me from writing the truth which some people are twisting on purpose to support their pleasure seeking behaviour.

In my following argument I will totally avoid any technical term such as abstract mathematical ideas like real/complex vector spaces, bra-ket, conjugates, Hermitian operators, Hamiltonian, Eigen etc. so the folks who do not have any idea of what quantum physics is can also follow this discussion.

Let us assume that we have two metal balls which are detectable because of their physical properties. If force applied on these balls they can move and interact. This is our first observation.

In case we move the metal balls closer and they start influencing each other without even interacting physically that gives us an understanding that these balls also have some indiscernible properties. When these balls start attracting or repelling each other this behaviour leads us to our knowledge of magnetism. This is our second observation which is indirect in nature.

Conclusion: Metal balls are directly detectable due to their physical properties. However, magnetic fields are detectable only when those fields start influencing other objects.

In today’s world it is a common knowledge that atoms are not the fundamental particles and they are also made of even smaller particles.

Atoms are made of nanoscopic balls called Fermions and the force those fermions carry are known as Bosons. When force fields (bosons) interact they can influence fermions to behave in certain ways. Fermions are detectable due their physical properties and bosons are detectable indirectly by the way fermions behave during their interactions.

By the word particle the first idea which may occur in mind is about something that is solid and that has detectable physical properties such as colour, shape, mass, etc. The force field on the other hand is not detectable until it interacts with something. However, scientists decided to put both fermions and bosons (force fields) under the same category of particles in quantum physics. Both fermions and bosons are called particles and that is the point when things start getting fuzzy for a person who is not well educated in science.

When two electrons approach each other, their charges create a disturbance. This disturbance pushes them apart and their paths bent outwards. In case of electron and positron the disturbance is similar in type but different in details so oppositely charged electron and positron attract each other and their paths are bent inwards. In other words, when two fermions interact their force fields mediates a force that changes their momentum and path of motion.

Many scientists push the idea that when two force fields interact together there is an exchange of undetectable particles (the Virtual Particles or Photons) that cause the attraction or repulsion among interacting fermions which carry those force fields. As if force fields are made of invisible particles which push or attract each other when they come near to each other. But this is just a Jargon because force fields are not detectable directly and nobody knows what exactly is happening inside those interacting fields. Scientists call those interactions of force fields “Exchange of Virtual Particles.” They call these particles “Virtual” because:

They are not detectable directly
They would never be found on their own
They do not have energy to become a well formed ripple moving through space and
They decay as soon as their causes are gone.

This is what a “Virtual Particle” and some people are twisting this idea to spread a false concept that at quantum level “Virtual Particles (as if REAL PARTICLES)” can appear out of nowhere.

This concept is wrong for one more reason. In modern physics there is no such thing as empty space. Fields pervade space. They are conditions and properties of space. The vacuum is filled with electromagnetic fields which are active and dynamic and within these fields always some activities are happening at nanoscopic levels. These fields are not smooth and fluctuations may cause energy-mass-energy conversions at small levels. In no way one can claim that energy-mass-energy conversions happen out of nothing because an unfathomable ocean of fluctuating fields provide a good solid base for such activities.

Saying that “Virtual Particles” can come into existence from nothing is a deliberate abuse of science. To me it seems that people who resist the idea of God are putting another effort to spin layman’s head with a false concept. Just like they did it by spreading the idea of Natural Selection without giving intelligible mechanism for Natural Selection.
Reply
RE: Natural Order and Science
(March 8, 2016 at 10:53 am)little_monkey Wrote: Your post illustrates perfectly what I was implying: since you have no way to differentiate between what is true or false, then your proposal "our beings encompass a huge amount of data stored in our conscience, a gift of nature, blah,blah...' is just another statement that has no validity. The question you should be asking: how can one differentiate a crackpot theory from the real thing? If you have no test to differentiate these two, then your theory is no more and no less valid than any other crackpot theory. So you can advance the idea that "our beings encompass a huge amount of data stored in our conscience, a gift of nature, blah, blah..."but it is no different than any other crackpot theory.

Are you saying that you can differentiate all truths of nature because you have handful knowledge about the physical world?

Has your scientific knowledge brought you any jackpot theory about your own life?

Are you saying you have followed strictly laws of physics in making all your emotional decisions in your life?

If you are saying all that then I do not believe you.
Reply



Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Relationship between programming languages and natural languages FlatAssembler 13 4631 June 12, 2023 at 9:39 pm
Last Post: The Valkyrie
  Does a natural "god" maybe exist? Skeptic201 19 6367 November 27, 2022 at 7:46 am
Last Post: BrianSoddingBoru4
  The difference between computing and science. highdimensionman 0 863 February 25, 2022 at 11:54 am
Last Post: highdimensionman
  In Defense of a Non-Natural Moral Order Acrobat 84 25233 August 30, 2019 at 3:02 pm
Last Post: LastPoet
  Do Humans have a Natural State? Shining_Finger 13 5026 April 1, 2016 at 4:42 am
Last Post: robvalue
  The relationship between Science and Philosophy Dolorian 14 8466 October 3, 2014 at 11:27 pm
Last Post: HopOnPop
  Natural Laws, and Causation. TheBigOhMan 3 2610 June 4, 2013 at 11:45 pm
Last Post: TheBigOhMan
  Shit man, im a natural born killer! Disciple 37 22786 April 28, 2012 at 8:57 pm
Last Post: Cinjin



Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)