Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: November 16, 2026, 7:53 am

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Do you believe in free will?
RE: Do you believe in free will?
(March 16, 2012 at 8:48 am)genkaus Wrote: We are retreading old ground.

Yep, hence why I agreed its not relevant to discuss it again.

Quote:Finally, the Golden Mean fallacy - to my understanding - requires acceptance of common understanding of two contradictory positions and then try to find a common ground. My position relies of rejection of the common understanding - thus making it probably more controversial.

and by default, more incomprehensible. Sorry.
Self-authenticating private evidence is useless, because it is indistinguishable from the illusion of it. ― Kel, Kelosophy Blog

If you’re going to watch tele, you should watch Scooby Doo. That show was so cool because every time there’s a church with a ghoul, or a ghost in a school. They looked beneath the mask and what was inside?
The f**king janitor or the dude who runs the waterslide. Throughout history every mystery. Ever solved has turned out to be. Not Magic.
― Tim Minchin, Storm
Reply
RE: Do you believe in free will?
(March 16, 2012 at 6:44 am)tackattack Wrote: The brain is physical. The mind is mental. The agent of self is a mental attribute. Free will is also a mental attribute. I believe will is not forced or predetermined by cusal chains outside of any influence. These abstracts or insubstantials hold no material space as the brain does, therefore they're seperate from the material. Therefore I believe that there are more than determined and material things that exist in reality. I believe reality exists in in more than just material substance.

As I see, your position on free-will is derived from following metaphysical assumptions.

1. There are two separate components of reality - physical and non-physical (which could be alternatively referred to as mental).

2. The mental component is not only separate from, but independent of the physical component. That is the only way it could exist while remaining independent of certain laws governing the physical component - specifically - the law of causation.


Now, what other conclusions can be drawn form these premises?

1. Since you have argued that the mental could exist independently of the physical, but never argued the other way around - either the physical reality is also independent of the mental reality or it is dependent upon it.

2. Since the implications of these assumptions are very much a part of physical reality - the physical reality is not independent of the mental one, but dependent upon it.

3. Therefore, the mental reality holds primacy over the physical - that is, in any apparent contradictions regarding the facts - the laws of this mental reality would supersede the laws of physical reality.

Now, let us look at some laws of physical reality that would not be applicable to the mental reality.

1. As stated, the law of causation does not apply to mental reality.

2. The law of causation is a necessary consequence of law of identity (an entity is what it is and can only act according to its nature). Therefore, the law of identity is not applicable as well.

3. The entire body of rational inquiry is based on the law of identity - therefore reason and logic as means of gaining knowledge of the mental reality are useless.

So, until now, based on your assumptions, we've gathered following facts about your position - that you believe in a reality beyond the physical reality. that you consider this reality to hold primacy, that you do not have any rational way to know anything about this reality and that between any apparent conflict of facts between this reality and the physical one, you'd choose to accept the other one.

Is it just me or is this position dangerously close to a fundamentalist one?

Moving on from the logical implications of your assumption to the assumptions themselves. Do you have any justification by which you hold these assumptions?

(March 16, 2012 at 8:58 am)NoMoreFaith Wrote: and by default, more incomprehensible. Sorry.

If it was easily comprehensible, then there wouldn't be a need for a discussion, since everyone would be able to figure it out for themselves. Wink Shades
Reply
RE: Do you believe in free will?
You have rejected both and yet objectively shown nothing.

You can state "Yes I have" but its obvious you have not. A concept obfuscated from scrutiny is not truly a concept.
Self-authenticating private evidence is useless, because it is indistinguishable from the illusion of it. ― Kel, Kelosophy Blog

If you’re going to watch tele, you should watch Scooby Doo. That show was so cool because every time there’s a church with a ghoul, or a ghost in a school. They looked beneath the mask and what was inside?
The f**king janitor or the dude who runs the waterslide. Throughout history every mystery. Ever solved has turned out to be. Not Magic.
― Tim Minchin, Storm
Reply
RE: Do you believe in free will?
(March 16, 2012 at 10:56 am)NoMoreFaith Wrote: You have rejected both and yet objectively shown nothing.

You can state "Yes I have" but its obvious you have not. A concept obfuscated from scrutiny is not truly a concept.

I think my posts speak for themselves.
Reply
RE: Do you believe in free will?
(March 16, 2012 at 11:03 am)genkaus Wrote: I think my posts speak for themselves.

We can agree wholeheartedly on that. Tongue
Self-authenticating private evidence is useless, because it is indistinguishable from the illusion of it. ― Kel, Kelosophy Blog

If you’re going to watch tele, you should watch Scooby Doo. That show was so cool because every time there’s a church with a ghoul, or a ghost in a school. They looked beneath the mask and what was inside?
The f**king janitor or the dude who runs the waterslide. Throughout history every mystery. Ever solved has turned out to be. Not Magic.
― Tim Minchin, Storm
Reply
RE: Do you believe in free will?
I'm going to interject a notion.

As I consider the mind to be exactly the same thing as the brain, I consider 'free will' to be the capability for my genetics and experiences to effectively make me do things, so while I am being 'forced' to do something, it is the decision of my brain and therefore also the decision of my mind, since they're the same. Get it?

I consider 'free will' the capability of nature and nurture to make you pursue a course, so therefore it exists based upon my materialist definition.
Reply
RE: Do you believe in free will?
(March 16, 2012 at 8:09 pm)R-e-n-n-a-t Wrote: I consider 'free will' the capability of nature and nurture to make you pursue a course, so therefore it exists based upon my materialist definition.

Yep, I get it. But its no longer "free" will.

There seems to be a lot of twisting of language in order to avoid admissions that we are not free.

I don't mean that negatively, simply put, we want to think of ourselves as free agents, but perhaps its enough to accept the illusion of free will, and quite literally not think about it too much Smile
Self-authenticating private evidence is useless, because it is indistinguishable from the illusion of it. ― Kel, Kelosophy Blog

If you’re going to watch tele, you should watch Scooby Doo. That show was so cool because every time there’s a church with a ghoul, or a ghost in a school. They looked beneath the mask and what was inside?
The f**king janitor or the dude who runs the waterslide. Throughout history every mystery. Ever solved has turned out to be. Not Magic.
― Tim Minchin, Storm
Reply
RE: Do you believe in free will?
I agree with you. The idea of a transcendent mind capable of making decisions beyond what genetics and society have caused is impossible. However, since the brain is the person, and the brain causes the action, it's still 'free' for the brain. The real debate should be about the definition of free will, I think. It sounds like most of the people here are getting hung up on the definition rather than the consenus.
Reply
RE: Do you believe in free will?
(March 17, 2012 at 5:25 am)R-e-n-n-a-t Wrote: I agree with you. The idea of a transcendent mind capable of making decisions beyond what genetics and society have caused is impossible. However, since the brain is the person, and the brain causes the action, it's still 'free' for the brain. The real debate should be about the definition of free will, I think. It sounds like most of the people here are getting hung up on the definition rather than the consenus.

How so? Name me one 'action' that any single neuron in the brain can make that isn't a result of an interaction with various other stimuli.

.
Reply
RE: Do you believe in free will?
"There ought to be a term that would designate those who actually follow the teachings of Jesus, since the word 'Christian' has been largely divorced from those teachings, and so polluted by fundamentalists that it has come to connote their polar opposite: intolerance, vindictive hatred, and bigotry." -- Philip Stater, Huffington Post

always working on cleaning my windows- me regarding Johari
Reply



Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Do you believe in free will? Disagreeable 37 9239 August 4, 2024 at 7:15 am
Last Post: Disagreeable
  Understanding the rudiment has much to give helps free that mind for further work. highdimensionman 16 4578 May 24, 2022 at 6:31 am
Last Post: highdimensionman
  Free Will Debate Alan V 82 24289 November 27, 2021 at 7:08 pm
Last Post: The Grand Nudger
  A 'proof' of God's existence - free will mrj 54 18991 August 9, 2020 at 10:25 am
Last Post: Sal
  Oh no not another free will thread. Edwardo Piet 309 102252 April 29, 2018 at 11:45 am
Last Post: The Grand Nudger
  WLC, Free Will, and God's divine foreknowledge SuperSentient 15 6737 April 1, 2017 at 2:50 am
Last Post: bennyboy
  Why free will probably does not exist, and why we should stop treating people - WisdomOfTheTrees 22 9738 February 8, 2017 at 7:43 pm
Last Post: WisdomOfTheTrees
  The Definitive Post On The Free Will v. Determinism Debate BrianSoddingBoru4 17 6772 September 3, 2016 at 11:20 pm
Last Post: Arkilogue
  Free Will Excited Penguin 112 36497 September 1, 2016 at 1:06 pm
Last Post: Angrboda
  free will Sappho 25 7526 August 16, 2016 at 8:59 am
Last Post: Edwardo Piet



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)