Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: November 16, 2026, 4:39 am

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
We should take the Moral Highground
#71
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
(April 6, 2012 at 10:34 am)ChadWooters Wrote: While I remain hopeful that reason could find a definitive basis for morality, I do not think a compelling refutation of nihilism has yet been presented.

Why is that required for the purpose of this thread? Secular morality is superior to religious morality if for no other reason than its relative clarity on the matter (or lack of conflict of interest).
Atheist Forums Hall of Shame:
"The trinity can be equated to having your cake and eating it too."
...      -Lucent, trying to defend the Trinity concept
"(Yahweh's) actions are good because (Yahweh) is the ultimate standard of goodness. That’s not begging the question"
...       -Statler Waldorf, Christian apologist
Reply
#72
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
Reply
#73
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
"A casual stroll through the lunatic asylum shows that faith does not prove anything." -Friedrich Nietzsche

"All thinking men are atheists." -Ernest Hemmingway

"Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities." -Voltaire
Reply
#74
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
(April 6, 2012 at 10:51 am)mediamogul Wrote: What is the basis for nihilism absent the existence of god?
We can and do deem things as moral or immoral. The question lies in who or what serves as the ultimate standard or arbiter for determining which is which. In the absence of an ultimate standard or arbiter, each person is left on their own. The individual then becomes their own ultimate authority, each with equal claim for what is right and wrong, rational or irrational. While I could appeal to ideals like human dignity and ‘the golden rule’, another could deny both, and there would be no common thing to which either of us could point to prove the other wrong. The alternative is to assert the existence of some transcendent authority, principle or standard that applies to all individuals. Absent that true morality does not exist. No one has the ‘right’ to demand others behave in a particular way, because right do not exist. Appealing to reason is also insufficient. Saying that everyone should follow reason is just another unfounded assertion. Why should anyone be rational? This leaves power as the only ultimate authority. I call that nihilism.
Reply
#75
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
(April 6, 2012 at 12:11 pm)ChadWooters Wrote: We can and do deem things as moral or immoral. The question lies in who or what serves as the ultimate standard or arbiter for determining which is which.

I've mentioned the social contract before as you do later in this post.

Quote:In the absence of an ultimate standard or arbiter, each person is left on their own. The individual then becomes their own ultimate authority, each with equal claim for what is right and wrong, rational or irrational. While I could appeal to ideals like human dignity and ‘the golden rule’, another could deny both, and there would be no common thing to which either of us could point to prove the other wrong.

Anyone who denies the social contract is committing hypocrisy. How can you condone the treatment of another that you would not tolerate on you? Being unrepentantly evil toward our fellow sentients is logically inconsistent.

Quote:The alternative is to assert the existence of some transcendent authority, principle or standard that applies to all individuals.

Actually, appealing to or asserting the existence of God does nothing to elucidate either our understanding of what is moral or what morality is. All it does is move the problem back a step and provide a needless factor in the problem.

In sum: GodWillsIt is just as unsatisfying to our need to understand ethical dilemmas as GodDidIt is unsatisfying to our need to unravel scientific mysteries.

If God decides on morality, as a celestial lawgiver, this is still arbitrary and subjective morality by definition. Appeals to God's authority in such matters is the essence of might-makes-right that you are trying to avoid. No matter how wise, powerful or trusted God may be, if God decides what is or isn't moral, this is not an objective standard by definition.

If God determines what is moral, as a celestial arbiter, then morality exists outside of God and can be discovered by our own inquiries. That which is right and wrong would continue to remain so even if God went away, changed Its mind or turned out never to have existed in the first place.

Christians, aware of this dilemma, are known to babble about how it's both and neither one. The babble usually goes something along the lines of "the essence of goodness is grounded in the very nature of God and so God neither decides what is moral nor discovers it but simply is." If I'm not quite representing the attempted escape clause correctly, please forgive me but I think that's the jist. The problems with this apologetic drivel are legion:

1. WTF does it even mean? "Essence of goodness"? Is it a substance in the body of a deity? Are there goodness molecules? This bare assertion borders on the incoherent.
2. It's a bare assertion.
3. It's prone to circular pitfalls. How do we know Yahweh is good? Because Yahweh is good. And that's how we know that Yahweh's will is good because goodness is Yahweh's will. Yahweh wills what he wills and so his will is always good because goodness is bound into his will.
4. It's a contrived definition to arrive at the desired conclusion.
5. It only moves the dilemma one step back. Does Yahweh decide what his nature is? If so, it's arbitrary. If not, goodness exists as a standard outside of Yahweh.

Quote: Absent that true morality does not exist. No one has the ‘right’ to demand others behave in a particular way, because right do not exist. This leaves power as the only ultimate authority. I call that nihilism.

I call that the false dilemma fallacy.
Atheist Forums Hall of Shame:
"The trinity can be equated to having your cake and eating it too."
...      -Lucent, trying to defend the Trinity concept
"(Yahweh's) actions are good because (Yahweh) is the ultimate standard of goodness. That’s not begging the question"
...       -Statler Waldorf, Christian apologist
Reply
#76
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
"A casual stroll through the lunatic asylum shows that faith does not prove anything." -Friedrich Nietzsche

"All thinking men are atheists." -Ernest Hemmingway

"Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities." -Voltaire
Reply
#77
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
(April 6, 2012 at 1:05 pm)DeistPaladin Wrote: I've mentioned the social contract before as you do later in this post....Anyone who denies the social contract is committing hypocrisy. How can you condone the treatment of another that you would not tolerate on you? Being unrepentantly evil toward our fellow sentients is logically inconsistent.

Any 'social contract' requires both agreement and enforcement. What if I don't agree? Who's going to make me obey? Suppose, my only goal is to get what I want and evade punishment. I do not care about the well-being of anyone but my self. Sure that makes me a hypocrite. But why is it inherently wrong to be duplicitous? I don't believe in evil so what am I supposed to repent. You say I have to be logical, because it's the right thing to do. What makes it right?

I would like to remind you that the OP is about athesim having the high moral ground. If you want the high moral ground, then you must do more that show theism to be inadequate. You must present a valid non-theistic basis for morality and demonstrate that it is superior. Otherwise, atheism is utlimately amoral. Or at least not inherently any more moral than theism
Reply
#78
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
(April 6, 2012 at 4:27 pm)ChadWooters Wrote: Any 'social contract' requires both agreement and enforcement. What if I don't agree?

Then you should either live as a hermit outside of society or you would be a hypocrite.

Quote:Who's going to make me obey?

Society. Specifically, law enforcement.

Quote:I would like to remind you that the OP is about athesim having the high moral ground. If you want the high moral ground, then you must do more that show theism to be inadequate. You must present a valid non-theistic basis for morality and demonstrate that it is superior.

I've already done this. "Conflict of interest" ring any bells? I have yet to hear any refutation from you.

Quote:Otherwise, atheism is utlimately amoral. Or at least not inherently any more moral than theism

Atheism itself is a lack of a belief, not a belief. It would have to be something to be amoral. What I have demonstrated is that not only is theism not helpful, it's actually harmful to our understanding of morality. Hence, secularism is morally superior.
Atheist Forums Hall of Shame:
"The trinity can be equated to having your cake and eating it too."
...      -Lucent, trying to defend the Trinity concept
"(Yahweh's) actions are good because (Yahweh) is the ultimate standard of goodness. That’s not begging the question"
...       -Statler Waldorf, Christian apologist
Reply
#79
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
DeistPaladin Wrote:Actually, appealing to or asserting the existence of God does nothing to elucidate either our understanding of what is moral or what morality is. All it does is move the problem back a step and provide a needless factor in the problem.

In sum: GodWillsIt is just as unsatisfying to our need to understand ethical dilemmas as GodDidIt is unsatisfying to our need to unravel scientific mysteries.

To expand on this, I have seen two methods offered for how god dictates morality. One is divine revelation which as we've seen with how many ways people can interperet the bible means what is derived as morality from the bible actually stems from what is already inside of us. The second method is that god instills with an innate sense of morality, which as DP as pointed out, does nothing to understand our knowledge of what comprise these morals and what they rely on. Even if god did dictate in morality this way, we must still search for what this innate sense of morality actually means, and brining god into the equation does nothing to further the discussion of what is moral.

In short, regardless of whether you believe we evolved morals or god instilled them, they still stem from our own desires and wishes. Be they objective or subjective morals, divine will or evolution at work, they are filtered through our own interperetations of the world. This filter is what we should be striving to understand.
Even if the open windows of science at first make us shiver after the cozy indoor warmth of traditional humanizing myths, in the end the fresh air brings vigor, and the great spaces have a splendor of their own - Bertrand Russell
Reply
#80
RE: We should take the Moral Highground
If my brothers asks for me money I let him have it, if a friend needs help I'll give it my all, if I see a poor guy I'll give him a pound or two.
That doesn't mean I have some omnipotent being showing me the "righteous path". It simply means I'm not a dick.
The people who find it repulsive to do this stuff are often unpleasant to be around due to their unpleasant nature. Someone who repels others doesn't help himself by doing so.

In-short; co-operation is preferable to isolation.
Reply



Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  My take on one of the arguments about omnipotence ShinyCrystals 9 3374 September 4, 2023 at 2:57 pm
Last Post: BrianSoddingBoru4
  Conscience and the Moral Argument as Evidence for the Goodness of God. Nishant Xavier 162 43365 July 9, 2023 at 7:53 am
Last Post: Deesse23
  Moral universalism and theism Interaktive 20 6222 May 6, 2022 at 7:23 pm
Last Post: The Grand Nudger
  Don't take it personally. Mystic 83 23298 October 16, 2018 at 12:52 pm
Last Post: Abaddon_ire
  Religion stifles Moral Evolution Cecelia 107 37165 December 4, 2017 at 2:37 pm
Last Post: Astreja
  Does religion expose the shortcomings of empathy based moral systems henryp 19 6334 December 2, 2017 at 7:54 pm
Last Post: henryp
  What godly miracle would it take? Astonished 48 24053 October 8, 2017 at 11:01 pm
Last Post: The Grand Nudger
  Creationist Moral Panic Amarok 15 9123 June 13, 2017 at 10:42 am
Last Post: Mister Agenda
Question How Much Evidence Will It Take You To Believe In God??? Edward John 370 117500 November 16, 2016 at 4:03 am
Last Post: robvalue
  The Moral Argument for God athrock 211 82790 December 24, 2015 at 4:53 am
Last Post: robvalue



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)