RE: The Last Movie You Watched
April 23, 2019 at 12:38 am
(This post was last modified: April 23, 2019 at 12:48 am by Rev. Rye.)
This week in the Deep Hurting Project is the Dinesh D'Souza "documentary" Hilary's America, and just looking into the opening credits, you know it's going to suck. You start off with D'Souza sitting in a tux at a piano, giving a touch of class to the movie (at least if you ignore his Colbert-like voice), and he introduced a band playing "Happy Days are Here Again," while cutout images of racism juxtaposed with imagery from the Democratic Party, up to and including equating it for the Confederacy. Um, Dinesh, which party has been fighting tooth and nail to maintain a positive image of the Confederacy? Which party has maintained a lock on the former Confederate states since the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1965? Which party recently had a high-profile Senate candidate recently claim that America was last great when we still had slavery (admittedly, after the film was released)?
Some highlights of the first ten minutes of stupidity:
You know what, it's pretty late, and I want to go to bed. So, I'll just leave it here. If there's any more stupid shit in the last 36 minutes of the film I can talk about (and no doubt there will be), I'll cover it tomorrow. And now that it looks like my second genre cycle through the list is done, maybe I'll revisit the Deep Hurting Project Awards and update them (some stay the same, some change, and some new categories get added.)
Some highlights of the first ten minutes of stupidity:
- The movie starts with D'Souza relating the story about how he turned out to be the only American dumb enough to violate campaign law, even though there are a myriad of ways to legally bribe them with an unlimited amount of money. Something he admits. For the third time in the Deep Hurting Project's history, I ask:
- It is somehow unacceptable for the president to "reward a dictatorial regime." Even though the US has done this constantly; just to nations the US actually likes.
- Obama is terrible for doubling the national debt, but Dubya and Reagan, who've both increased it by a higher percentage, get a free pass.
- The rise of ISIS somehow has nothing to do with Bush's War on Terror that led to a lot of Middle Easterners to have many legitimate grievances with the US.
- If you make a film criticising Obama, he will send you up the river on trumped up charges. Somehow, the dozens of films criticizing Bush, from the documentaries who called him out directly, to comedy films who made films that treated him as a buffoon, were left untouched.
- Does he seriously think people think FDR founded the Democratic Party? And not Thomas Jefferson? Seriously, with all the complicated views on slavery you can mangle, made all the more public with the success of Hamilton, where he's the main non-Burr antagonist of Act II, making hay of his slave-fucking would seem like fish in a barrel, so why not do it.
- And notice that his understanding of the public opinion of Andrew Jackson, he's about 40+ years out of date. The consensus has become pretty clear that, whatever positives he may have had, he was probably the most morally bankrupt President of all time. At least until our current President, who, well...
- To be fair, there was a National Republican party that opposed Andrew Jackson, so this is far less stupid than I thought. That said, I strongly suspect he's blatantly overestimating the goodness of that faction. This was, after all, the faction that supported John Quincy Adams, and put him into the presidency with the lowest margin of victory until Rutherford Hayes and Donald Trump
- Slavery was a form of theft? And that was the worst thing about it?
- While Stephen Douglas was pretty pro-slavery as Dinesh mentions, he still did whatever he could to prevent secession after it was clear he would lose to an anti-slavery candidate and the South wanted to secede.
- No Republican ever owned slaves? Not quite.
- All Suffragettes were Republicans? Even the ones outside of America?
- The Klan was not the military wing of the Democratic Party any more than The Proud Boys are the military wing of today's Republicans.
- They cover the lynching of Sam Hose, and focus on Ida B. Wells and never mention the crucial influence it had on W.E.B. du Bois.
- Obama did nothing to change the plantation-like nature of the inner cities. Somehow the fact that so little has changed has nothing to do with the Republican party shutting down discussion on not just any change, but damn near anything.
- Okay, in the 1920s, lynching was apparently taboo in the Democratic Party, requiring a more eugenical approach, but in the 1930s, refusing to allow change on the lynching issue was vital for the New Deal. Something about this does not fit. Given that Margaret Sanger, far from wishing to exterminate the black race, was actually pretty damn non-bigoted for her era, it's clear to see what the problem is.
- In the category of shooting fish in a barrel and still missing, there's Saul Alinsky. You could claim he was some nefarious political mind, which would certainly fit in the sort of narrative you're trying to push, and the most damning thing we see him do was ripping off automats for a fucking nickel. Good fucking God, Chapo made a lot of hay over this shit alone. Line I'm far too Goyish to ever get away with: "How is it stealin' if they have th' noive to charge a quarter for a sandwich? Such bad food, and so little of it!" Actually a nickel, but still.
- The prison scenes look like they were filmed in an empty warehouse. Seriously, I don't know how much money went into the Em City set for Oz, but no matter how much, they clearly did a lot more with it.
- We've got a Californian prisoner pronouncing it "IN-shurns" and not "in-SUR-ance."
- Also, Larry David must have been hit with hard times, since it looks like he's living in the shitty parts of Chicago.
- I really don't want to dive deep into the Dinesh D'Souza oeuvre, but was he seriously that ignorant that the racism was originally promulgated by the Democratic Party before Goldwater, before he went to prison? I get the feeling that the ideas he's treating as a major post-prison revelation were all shit he knew and talked about before.
- Also, Dinesh can somehow go into the restricted areas of a museum and fuck with which exhibits go on display with total impunity.
- The Klan scene is projected in The White House in the Wilson Era, and it's apparently scored with "Un bel dì vedremo" despite there being no live or pre-recorded soundtrack to the film (also, I watched the Kino version with the original score years ago, and I don't think Puccini was part of it; Grieg, yes, but no Puccini) and also, I'm fairly certain they didn't have a print where the Klan rode off the screen.
- LBJ was almost unrecognisable without him whipping out Jumbo.
You know what, it's pretty late, and I want to go to bed. So, I'll just leave it here. If there's any more stupid shit in the last 36 minutes of the film I can talk about (and no doubt there will be), I'll cover it tomorrow. And now that it looks like my second genre cycle through the list is done, maybe I'll revisit the Deep Hurting Project Awards and update them (some stay the same, some change, and some new categories get added.)
Comparing the Universal Oneness of All Life to Yo Mama since 2010.
I was born with the gift of laughter and a sense the world is mad.
I was born with the gift of laughter and a sense the world is mad.