Why I Joined This Forum For My Work I Was Asked

[The Valkyrie]

Here is why
---
Deesse23
Then why do you plan on revealing your awesome work in this insignificant forum of all places in the world? Why arent you already debating the most well-educated and experienced scholars? Who don't i read in newspapers and hear on TV about your findings?
---

There is a significant reason why I chose this forum, of all places in the world. I am creating a video that introduces my extensive research about the false claims regarding the marriage of Aisha (RA) and the allegations that the Prophet (PBUH) was a pedophile.
This video begins with a man sitting in front of his computer, looking to engage in discussions with atheists, so he joins this Atheist Forum. Instead of finding a welcoming group, he is met with substantial hostility from his first post to the last. The debate raged on for about seven hours, with 22 atheists against one.
The initial accusations thrown at him included, 'Your prophet was a dog,' 'Muhammad was a pedophile,' and so forth. I was attacked from every direction by everyone. After that night, I spent 13 years researching why these claims were made against the Prophet (PBUH).
I have never forgotten that night, and it drove me to return here to see how the forum would react if I approached gently, hoping at least for a fair hearing and a chance to move past those hostilities.
Unfortunately, even my posting of the Table of Contents for my research was met with accusations of advertising, which is incorrect. And my third post has also been removed. I am now recording all posts and have never been more convinced that achieving peace between Islam and atheists will be challenging—not because of Islam, but because of the initial belligerence from non-believers. Another lost opportunity for humanity to find amicability and tolerance.

I am now contented and have sufficient material. Even if this is also deleted. Know that I have everything print screened in my archives. It is another proof that atheists can never stand against man to man with a scholar of Islam. My last word - You will come to hear about this soon all over the world not too long from now.

Al-Amiyr
01 April 2025

I tried to be tolerant and you just started posting absolute and utter bullshit.

So nice that we, once again, get a "tolerant" Muslim threatening us as he leaves.

Fuck you.
Fuck your threats.
Fuck your pedo prophet.

Beccs
Today, tomorrow, and every day in the future.

[Alan V]

I find it rather bizarre that Al-Amiyr solicited atheists' most negative views about Muhammad and then got offended by them.  Didn't he know about all of such views before?

The reason why there likely will be no peace and tolerance between Muslims and atheists is because Muslims think atheists go to hell, that merely not believing is intolerable.  Condescension and contempt are built right into Islamic assumptions about atheists.

If he approached atheists like any regular guy, I assume he would still be here.  Too bad.

[brewer]

I wonder who he is/was a sock of?

Can't seem to find that.  But his name is all over if you do an Internet search.  Lots of different forum entries and other things.

I'll wait till the book comes out...or not...to learn more.

Using AI and just so darn cute that the first letter of the chapter names spell out other words...so darn clever.

I may have found him: https://atheistforums.org/user-2901.html

I know, I know,...........I need to get a life.

[Sheldon]

Here is why
---
Deesse23
Then why do you plan on revealing your awesome work in this insignificant forum of all places in the world? Why arent you already debating the most well-educated and experienced scholars? Who don't i read in newspapers and hear on TV about your findings?
---

There is a significant reason why I chose this forum, of all places in the world. I am creating a video that introduces my extensive research about the false claims regarding the marriage of Aisha (RA) and the allegations that the Prophet (PBUH) was a pedophile.
This video begins with a man sitting in front of his computer, looking to engage in discussions with atheists, so he joins this Atheist Forum. Instead of finding a welcoming group, he is met with substantial hostility from his first post to the last. The debate raged on for about seven hours, with 22 atheists against one.
The initial accusations thrown at him included, 'Your prophet was a dog,' 'Muhammad was a pedophile,' and so forth. I was attacked from every direction by everyone. After that night, I spent 13 years researching why these claims were made against the Prophet (PBUH).
I have never forgotten that night, and it drove me to return here to see how the forum would react if I approached gently, hoping at least for a fair hearing and a chance to move past those hostilities.
Unfortunately, even my posting of the Table of Contents for my research was met with accusations of advertising, which is incorrect. And my third post has also been removed. I am now recording all posts and have never been more convinced that achieving peace between Islam and atheists will be challenging—not because of Islam, but because of the initial belligerence from non-believers. Another lost opportunity for humanity to find amicability and tolerance.

I am now contented and have sufficient material. Even if this is also deleted. Know that I have everything print screened in my archives. It is another proof that atheists can never stand against man to man with a scholar of Islam. My last word - You will come to hear about this soon all over the world not too long from now.

Al-Amiyr
01 April 2025

I don't think atheism means what you think it does, as it carries no burden of proof, and requires no argument, anymore than not believing in mermaids does. I also don't care for your vapid threat at the end of that disjointed rant. If you don't like atheists and what they have to say, they're pretty easy to avoid. I wish the same could be said of your religion, which in many parts of the world is still not a choice people can refuse. 

As far as your beliefs go, I have one question only, what objective evidence (if any) can you demonstrate that any deity exists, or is even possible? If you have none then you might as well be citing scholars in Harry Potter novels.

[Astreja]

The reason why there likely will be no peace and tolerance between Muslims and atheists is because Muslims think atheists go to hell, that merely not believing is intolerable.  Condescension and contempt are built right into Islamic assumptions about atheists.

Some flavours of religion are completely incompatible with tolerance.  "Peace" = "Come over to our side, or we'll destroy you."

Respect has to be given; it cannot be demanded.  I will neither respect nor tolerate people or ideas that do not respect or tolerate me.

[Nay_Sayer]

OP you have rejected the light of FSM. You are cursed forever

[Angrboda]

Oddly enough, I just got up from an hour's rest imagining a discussion with a group leader who tossed my ass from a religious reading group many year's past. I guess resentment isn't purely religious.

[Thumpalumpacus]

Even if this is also deleted. Know that I have everything print screened in my archives. It is another proof that atheists can never stand against man to man with a scholar of Islam.

Right, because Islamic countries are very tolerant of atheism.

You're being treated the way you treat others. Shut up with your complaints. If you want tolerance, grant it.

[Nay_Sayer]

I find it rather bizarre that Al-Amiyr solicited atheists' most negative views about Muhammad and then got offended by them.  Didn't he know about all of such views before?

The reason why there likely will be no peace and tolerance between Muslims and atheists is because Muslims think atheists go to hell, that merely not believing is intolerable.  Condescension and contempt are built right into Islamic assumptions about atheists.

If he approached atheists like any regular guy, I assume he would still be here.  Too bad.

He was never here for honest discourse. If I had to guess he's done this many times before, joining atheist forums and the like to elicit negative replies. Then he gathers them for his book, which I doubt anyone will ever read. So he can point can say, "Look at how mean they are!"

I would expect more, but his particular holy book impels him to lie.

[Rev. Rye]

Here is why
---
Deesse23
Then why do you plan on revealing your awesome work in this insignificant forum of all places in the world? Why arent you already debating the most well-educated and experienced scholars? Who don't i read in newspapers and hear on TV about your findings?
---

---

There is a significant reason why I chose this forum, of all places in the world. I am creating a video that introduces my extensive research about the false claims regarding the marriage of Aisha (RA) and the allegations that the Prophet (PBUH) was a pedophile.
This video begins with a man sitting in front of his computer, looking to engage in discussions with atheists, so he joins this Atheist Forum. Instead of finding a welcoming group, he is met with substantial hostility from his first post to the last. The debate raged on for about seven hours, with 22 atheists against one.
The initial accusations thrown at him included, 'Your prophet was a dog,' 'Muhammad was a pedophile,' and so forth. I was attacked from every direction by everyone. After that night, I spent 13 years researching why these claims were made against the Prophet (PBUH).
I have never forgotten that night, and it drove me to return here to see how the forum would react if I approached gently, hoping at least for a fair hearing and a chance to move past those hostilities.
Unfortunately, even my posting of the Table of Contents for my research was met with accusations of advertising, which is incorrect. And my third post has also been removed. I am now recording all posts and have never been more convinced that achieving peace between Islam and atheists will be challenging—not because of Islam, but because of the initial belligerence from non-believers. Another lost opportunity for humanity to find amicability and tolerance.

I am now contented and have sufficient material. Even if this is also deleted. Know that I have everything print screened in my archives. It is another proof that atheists can never stand against man to man with a scholar of Islam. My last word - You will come to hear about this soon all over the world not too long from now.

Al-Amiyr
01 April 2025

---

If its true that you researched 13 years after being met with hostility on this forum, only to come back to this forum, then i suggest you get help, professional help. I am serious.

Oh, and fuck you for threatening me and everyone else.

A 13-year-old sock puppet? That was a very anticlimactic ending for this saga. Also, he ruminated over this for 13 years and, in all this time, he didn’t familiarize himself with the 30/30 rule?