Is nihilism the logical extreme of atheism?

[FatAndFaithless]

Forgive the bad formatting, posting from a phone.

You said

Good is what God has to be to be a creative singularity

Which is a flat assertion of what the preconditions of a creative singularity are, not to mention the supposition that singularities can be creative.

Also, that's not a theory, is a handful of guesses that can't be falsified or tested or examined.

[fr0d0]

Like I said fatty, I'd love to hear your defence of a self destructive or non creative creative singularity. In my mind that is completely contradictory, on a very basic level. You can't just keep saying "oh no it isn't" without offering some alternate proposition.

It's not a precondition. If it was then this isn't that singularity. Something came before.

[Chad32]

If you can't be god without being good, I think I can safely say that Yahweh is not god.

[FatAndFaithless]

Uh, actually I can. I can point at bullshit and call it what it is. The existence of and character of God are questions that I don't have an answer for. That's why I don't claim to have answer. I'm not arguing for anything, I'm saying your argument is circular, arbitrary and hopelessly flawed.

[fr0d0]

Yet the Jews defined him as that, and wrote their religious texts about a good God. You look at those texts and say, ooh, that looks like it hurt, and conclude that God isn't good. I say you misunderstand.

---

I'm saying your argument is circular, arbitrary and hopelessly flawed.

Yes you keep saying it. But you continually fail to back it up. There's a simple problem for you to address up there ^^, yet you're silent.

I'm not saying that you're opinion is flawed. I'm simply asking for a rational argument from you. In sure you wouldn't want me to change my thoughts without good reason. Or is that how you came to your opinions?

[FatAndFaithless]

LastPoet was right.

[fr0d0]

LastPoet was right.

To troll?

He has nothing else. He looks best that way.

[FatAndFaithless]

At this point I'm not even sure what you're trying to argue Frodo. It's a giant mishmash of presuppositions and circular reasoning. Congratulations pigeon, you've shat all over the chessboard, call it a victory if you like.

[fr0d0]

Towel, accepted.

[FatAndFaithless]

Might as well use it to clean your birdshit off the chessboard.