Dear Resident Theists

[Napoléon]

My point here is I believe the universe to be fine tuned to immense precision to support life only on this planet.  I don't believe there is life anywhere else.

First off, I recall you mentioning mathematical improbability. By the sheer number of planets, it's reasonable to assume there is at least one with conditions similar enough to those of Earth that life can exist....But I guess that's beside the point anyway.

It's actually precisely the point Neim. Kingpin reckon's there's no life elsewhere, that ours is a unique planet that's been fine tuned? I wonder what he'll say when we inevitably find it. Because we will. I think there's a really strong chance we could find evidence of life elsewhere in our lifetimes.

What he says implies... hell it pretty much states, that our planet is completely unique in it being fine tuned. That the entire universe is created and formed with the Earth in mind. There's no other planet out there like ours. That's demonstrably not the case, and it shows a real ignorance to modern astronomy. We've already found planets remarkably similar to Earth, and we're not even looking at a drop in the ocean of what's actually out there. I think most astronomers would probably estimate the amount of Earth like planets out there, numbers in the millions, if not billions, across the entire universe. Maybe more. We can also clearly see that the universe does not exist for the sole purposes of the Earth. There is no evidence of fine tuning, in fact the actual evidence implies the complete opposite.

Without a doubt our planet is not the only one out there with conditions suitable for life, and it is certainly not unique. To make the summation that our planet is unique and that it's the only one out there, is IMHO stupendously arrogant. Even if we haven't confirmed life elsewhere yet, there is no logical line of reasoning to assume that the Earth has been fine tuned. I'd go as far as to say that this viewpoint is diametrically opposed to what we (or should I say the scientists and astronomers) currently know about the universe. There are however very logical lines of reasoning to suggest that we're not alone out there.

It's easy to say "oh but we haven't found life yet", sure. But nobody truly knew the Earth was round until it was actually proven, but did that discount all the indications that it was indeed round, before the hypothesis was confirmed? Did it make the doubters any less ignorant?