Attack at Planned Parenthood Clinic

[Catholic_Lady]

Wow guys. I was NOT talking about sex/rape at alllll.  

I know you weren't, I was restating your argument in that way to show why one should not depend on the naturalistic fallacy as justification for one's position.  I was not intending to insinuate that you somehow supported or condoned rape, I know you don't. I was intending to show how that kind of argument (using the naturalistic fallacy), with only a few changes of words, can be used to justify both what people consider a moral position or behavior (a pro-life stance) and what people consider an immoral position or behavior (something like rape) in the same way I used it before (see the post with the Mr. Bean pic).

---

I've already PM'd Cathy but I wanted to let anyone who might be expecting a response from me know that I need to stop posting in this thread (personal reasons).  I'm sorry if you were hoping I'd respond, under other circumstances I would have stayed, but I really need to not participate in this thread anymore.

Ah, I see what you're saying. I don't agree that you can compare a fetus with a rapist, and conception with rape, though. Like I said in that post, it's not like a big bad baby forces his way into your body without permission lol. It's not his fault if he get's conceived there and it's not like he has a chance to ask for permission (that's just how conception works, that's the natural order of human reproduction). The same cannot be said about a rapist.