Thomas Kelly252525 Wrote:Mister Agenda Wrote:It is unwise to think anything is logical because it is popular (ad populum fallacy). It is also unwise to think something is illogical because it is popular.
Mister Agenda,
I'm not sure what you were thinking, maybe you just wanted to show your understanding of this.
I haven't been thinking if popular then logical or if popular then illogical.
What do you think about the subject of the thread ? Do you think it's right to use The No True Scotsman Fallacy against Christians if one Christian says that another person called a Christian, is not a Christian, if you have thoughts of 1 John 4:1 ?
You've provided no context, so we're just having a conversation with each other. I don't think much of the thread, the OP seems to be playing some kind of game. When you're actually ready to contribute your own thoughts, please feel free to jump in.
I've explained in detail what I think about a Christian saying another person called a Christian is not a Christian elsewhere.
I'm not anti-Christian. I'm anti-stupid.
