Should a woman be treated differently if...

[John V]

I agree, any person who shows up naked to a public place should be reprimanded, regardless of whether they are male or female. This is obvious. But as I said, I don't believe the spirit of the question was meant in this way. Notice how the OP specifically said "women" instead of just "person". He can correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm sure he is referring to our culture's objectification of women and their bodies. 

I disagree. The fact that he broke the responses into theist and atheist makes me suspect he was going for a gotcha moment. That suspicion is reinforced by all the no answers. Most people are answering the way they think they should, rather than being honest (I only skimmed the thread but IIRC Losty was an exception). The fact is that we treat people - male and female - differently based on how they're dressed all the time. The last two days I had client meetings and I wore a tie. Today no client meetings, so I'm just wearing a polo shirt. This isn't rocket surgery, and it's not a theist/atheist thing. Clothes matter. It's pretty simple. Everyone knows it.