On Logic and Alternate Universes

[FallentoReason]

We can't arrive at that truth using our logic, because our logic only works in this universe. But in a universe governed by goblygoop, 2 + 2 does equal 5. They could ask the same questions about our answer being 4, or not?

Ok, so after all this back and forth arguing between you and Rhythm, what should we take out of this exactly? That "goblygoop" is logical in that universe where "goblygoop" happens to be logical?

I'll grant you that. Now what? It's still not logical using our logic. So what's the point?

Have a look for yourself: http://atheistforums.org/thread-45714-po...pid1425952

You will only have to go 3 - 4 back-and-forths deep to get a gist of where this logic stuff sprang from.