On Logic and Alternate Universes

[Edwardo Piet]

SAtop.

What do you expect me to do when you keep saying "stop"? Throw my hands up in the air and pretend to agree with you?

 I'm not, I wont tell you again that it's not an issue of label in the hyopthetical.   The sum of 2 and 2 is 5, 5 is not a label for 4.  It is 5.

You do realize that 2 things and 2 things is the same thing as four things? Stop it with the use/mention fucking error. Two things and two things can't be 5 things because 5 things is more than four things. It doesn't matter what universe it is in that doesn't change the reality that something is not what it is not.

 The end...next time, I'll point and laugh.

Because you're another one of those people who doesn't like to be persistently disagreed with?

You also were the one who first resorted to insults. I'm sorry that I think you're wrong but I'm allowed to think you're wrong as much as you're allowed to think I'm wrong, there's no need to be an immature cunt about it. I can just as easily pin you as stubborn as vice-versa.

In this universe, 2+2=5, because, for example, when you add two things together, another, 5th thing materializes..

Ok, you're an idiot. You called me an idiot first and now, seriously, you're an idiot for thinking this. If another thing materializes it doesn't mean that two things and two things is the same as 5 things it means that two things and two things is still four things and another thing materializes but that's completely irrelevant

and their math reflects that.

"their math"? You talk about math like its truths are based on the concept of minds. They're not. Two things and two things is still four things whether there's a mind to conceptualize it or not. There is no "their math" and "our math", we're not talking about the concepts of logical and mathematical laws, remember, we're talking about the actual truths they refer to. The laws themselves. You're making another use/mention error. Two things and two things will always be equal to four things whether we call the answer "5" or not.